Get FREE BuzzFlash News Alerts

Email:  

New York Post Non-Apology for Racist Cartoon Makes Monkeys of Us All

A BUZZFLASH EDITOR'S BLOG

By Mark Karlin

A search of Google will reveal that most of the corporate mainstream press headlined that the New York Post had "apologized" for its racist cartoon depicting President Obama as a monkey. But the New York Post did not apologize by any common meaning of the word in a subsequent editorial: it defended the cartoon and mocked all fair-minded Americans by "apologizing" if the cartoon that the Post claimed was innocuous "offended" anyone.

In short, the fault lies in our eyes and sensitivities, the Post told us, not in their barely coded bigotry.  One of our regular BuzzFlash "lighter side" contributors is a cartoonist who got it right. As our "Pablo" observes in his toon entitled "Offended by Apology": "It was one of those 'If anyone was offended' apologies"; Well, "I'm offended at those who were not offended."

The non-apology "apology" is a staple response of Republicans who find that people have caught them wearing white hoods -- and invariably the corporate media accepts what is really another insult and defense of racism as an "apology."

Sean Delonas, the staff cartoonist at the Rupert Murdoch publication, has a long history of bigotry in his cartoons, as BuzzFlash revealed in a news alert.  You'd have to be brain dead, particularly with a photo of Obama and an NY Post attack on the "stimulus" plan preceding the racist cartoon, not to recognize what Delonas and the print counterpart to Murdoch's FOX News were up to.

On February 19th, we bestowed the BuzzFlash Media Putz of the Week "Award" on the New York Post:

It's not like the New York Post is known for taste or decorum anywhere in its ink-stained, tabloid, "I need a shower after I read it" pages. And there is a certain expectation that cartoons will occasionally be tacky. But a violent, degrading cartoon without a funny or relevant analogy is going far too far, and so we name the New York Post the Media PUTZ of the Week. 

White straight male Christian entitlement is what was the basis for the Civil War.  Rupert Murdoch -- in his media empire that includes the Post, FOX and the Wall Street Journal -- continually carries on that shameful tradition.

The New York Post and the other Murdoch media outlets remain unapologetic about making monkeys of us all. 

A BUZZFLASH EDITOR'S BLOG

Also recommended: The Zoo


 Fitch store in

 

Fitch store in general Abercrombie And Fitch , everything a good matrimony before marriage have nothing to retain the preceding "female mad batch - Abercrombie" part of the two is the first home in new york city a horde promotion sportswear for men and it is a successful lawyer, that is, fitch.Ezra fitch in a charge over a very intricate to read from the abercrombie is obstinate to read and long abercrombie & fitch. He's also very good brand Abercrombie and Fitch Hoodies, including Abercrombie And Fitch Clothing and Abercrombie and Fitch JeansAbercrombie and Fitch PantsAbercrombie and Fitch Tees. Has become a fashionable personage's first choice, Abercrombie and Fitch Sweaters is all over the world, of course, is also expected to Abercrombie and Fitch Shorts. New Year was coming, everyone wants new clothes to disguise themselves,Abercrombie Clothing is a good choice. BecauseAbercrombie Sale is a well-known brand, Abercrombie and Fitch Outerwearseverywhere, abercrombie is very much a Cheap Abercrombie. There has Abercrombie and Fitch PolosAbercrombie Womens and Abercrombie and Fitch Shirts. Personally, I'm looking forward to Abercrombie Hollister's 2009 New Arrivals, such as Abercrombie Ruehl No.925 like this style.

 

The cartoon is racist - the

The cartoon is racist - the non-apology is even more offensive and even more racist than the cartoon. I dont think inability to see the obvious is racist - I would just call it insensitive. If I had to choose who to throw off a ship - the racist or the insensitive guy - I would throw the racist off - but if the insensitive guy clings onto the racist and goes overboard with him that is okay.

I feel very very sorry for Americans who are prejudiced against Black Americans. Black Americans are the most intelligent race politically with less than 5 percent voting for Conservative Republicans. Asians vote Conservative Republican at a higher rate than Blacks. Hispanics vote Conservative Republican at a higher rate than Blacks. Whites vote Conservative Republican at a higher rate than Blacks. Why not listen to the political geniuses say?

Let's hear this explanation

How are the wingnuts going to explain away the Obama/Curious George material during the campaign? It was about how they love Obama as much as a beloved children's book character?

The Big Picture.

The cartoonist is not a racist, he is a moron. I'm suprised no one caught on to this sooner, but the guy just went after mankind in general, and there is so many metaphors in this thing I cannot believe it. First things first, I agree with people who say the "Monkey" is suppose to represent President Barack Obama, I'm sorry to all those who wish Al Sharpton to be wrong, but it's obviously the case. Also, the way the cop is saying it "They'll have to find someone else to write the next stimulus bill." Okay we all know grammar pretty well and that is phrased a little too much like an assassination attempt, opps Mr. Cartoonist, looks like you need to go back to primary school and fixed your word organization and sentence structure. But the extra point I would like to bring up about this cartoon, is has any body realized yet that not only did this guy go after President Obama, whether racially motivated or no, but also the NYPD as well! I mean come on, let us not forget that the NYPD hasn't always been the most racially consinous people in the world. I'm sorry but in the end this guys just a plain idiot, he asked for this and so did the whole NY Post staff, by allowing this cartoon to get published. If it was meant to be racist or not this guy sure did go about it the wrong way and leave this cartoon way to open to interpretation let us cover our butts next time and just but a stimulus bill being shot and avoid the backlash all together.

Wow...get over it..?

it is obvious that "You" have gotten over 500 years of exploitation degradation and cruety that has been and in many ways continues to be the american experience for blacks.. but others; who experience this reality daily have not.... and will not as long as there are mainstream ideas that they should "just get over it" Your comment just reveals the insentivity and ignorance that has allowed this kind of thinking and behavior to go on for too long... there is need for atonement and healing from this legacy... not justifcation or denial of it...

editing comment

Change "entitlement is what was the basis" to "entitlement was the basis." Much better. Meanwhile, I disagree that the Post's behavior - ie not really apologizing - makes monkeys of us. Rather, we'd have to accept the apology to be so designated.

Wow, Really. Its OBVIOUS

Wow, Really. Its OBVIOUS this is a joke against the writers of the stimulus, which was not obama who actually wrote it, as being as bright as a primate. It's not a hugely great idea. Definitely didnt take a genious to think of it. It is a joke against the stimulus bill, and only that. No certain person in particular. They could have used any other animal, and you still would have found some way to bitch about it. thats all us americans do. And I absolutely hate that everyone makes white people out to be sooo racist. Have you heard the way african americans talk about white people? ALL THE TIME. They are JUST AS BAD. neither is worse than the other. Both are in the wrong. So stop playing your poor me pitty cards. I grew up in a mainly african american city, and I was outcasted and made fun of because I was white. Is that not racist as well? So just stop. You all look too deep into these things. It would have been the same damn cartoon if we had a white president too. Everythign that is going to happen in the next 4 years is going to be looked at way too intensely to see if theres a way we can make it look like its racist. Get over it.

get over it..?

it is obvious that "You" have gotten over 500 years of exploitation degradation and cruety that has been and in many ways continues to be the american experience for blacks.. but others; who experience this reality daily have not.... and will not as long as there are mainstream ideas that they should "just get over it" Your comment just reveals the insentivity and ignorance that has allowed this kind of thinking and behavior to go on for too long... there is need for atonement and healing from this legacy... not justifcation or denial of it...

Get over it...

Almost free Slave labor, losing the Civil War, fighting unions, cheap "no-rights" labor, stupid red necks, KKK, fighting desegregation and integration, dumber-than-spit Southern politicians, fundamentalist dumber-than-spit religionists, Darwin and evolution, "get over it".

This is a racist cartoon

Dumb racist Joke: What does a chimp have to do with President Obama signing a bill?

why do you guys make it such

why do you guys make it such a big deal...I did not find anything racist with it. It is stupid to upload videos in response to it..come on don't waste the internet space with your crap..

Actually, it wouldn't.

If the original incident had involved any other animal that can harm humans, such as a bear, wolf, tiger or cape buffalo, the cartoon would never have been drawn, because it would have made no sense. What would two cops standing over a dead bear talking about the stimulus mean? The stimulus was written by Bear Bryant? Vermont Teddy Bears? Winnie the Pooh? The only way the cartoon works is to portray the stimulus as having been written by a monkey, which is one of the more common racist images. And complaining that black people speak ill of whites is like the victim of a crime is equal to the criminal.I'm surprised you have internet access in that outhouse.

Take off your white hood, maybe you'll see the light!

Just like it was no big deal when the Republicans were screaming at their pre-election rallies "Kill him, Kill him"!! No big deal when security became lax at one of the functions where Obama was at, because they claimed things were too out of hand for them to keep security tight. And just like the "skinheads" that made threats on Obama and were deemed to be "harmless". Yep, you hateful testosterone-driven bullies are just praying for an assassination so you can grab power again and totally destroy our country. You wear your racism on your sleeve and on your lips and by your very defense of this disgusting piece of trash. Trying to incite some more hatred and racism? You're a typical example of what brainwashing accomplishes. You would have had to have a brain to begin with in order to resist. Sorry you were AWOL when they were handed out.

you really shouldn't be

you really shouldn't be taking all that....please keep the comments short..looks like you can write a book given a chance...cut your bull shit...

You are the real racist

The cartoon refers to the author of the stimulus package. Congress not the President is the author, but you are one of those people who likes to throw the race card every chance you see through your black and white glasses. He penned not a word in the stimulus package. A google search of political cartoons shows that a monkey is the animal of choice for cartoonists. In this particular cartoon which was penned just after the shooting of the chimp in California, the cartoon depicts what happens when people act without thinking of the consequences.

Where does it say? A Google

Where does it say? A Google search as you specified shows no such thing. As you put it, "a google search of political cartoons" does absolutely Not show that the monkey is the "animal of choice" for caricaturing a Black American.

New York Post

Well, New York Post shouldn't have apologized for nothing because it was a cartoon. Idiots/Racists/ and Bigots that's complaining apparently doesn't know who wrote the Stimulus Bill. Obama didn't have anything to do with writing the Stimulus Bill just the dumbazzes of the Congress & Senate. Afro-Americans always wants to call everyone a Racist when they're the most racist group of people in this country. The American Indians are the only people in this country that have been discriminated against their entire life and haven't gotten anything in return. Did the idiot Al Sharpton apologize to the group of young men for falsely accusing them of raping a whatever you want to call her? No, he didn't he crawled back under the shell he came out from. I liked the cartoon and I'm not a RACIST. Plus, Obama is a Muslim not an Afro-American.

You are a Conservative

You are a Conservative Republican, obviously?

I'm sorry to tell you this

But your ignorance about even the most simple of facts and your obviously poor level of education renders your opinions meaningless. I can see why you are anonymous.

New York Post cartoon

It seems that you are a part of the problem rather than part of the solution. What is more, you are a racist and have writtn incredibly stupid utterings. Obama isn't a muslim, Native Americans are not the only people discriminated by in this country, and Obama absolutely had everything to do with the writing of the Stimulus package. And I call her Tawana Brawley. Rev. Sharpton is not always the sharpest tool in the tool box. You seem to reside along side of him there. As for the Post, I don't waste my money supporting Rupert Murdoch and his ilk. That cartoon is exactly the kind of tripe I expect from the Post.

Actually, you are indeed a racist and an ass

African-American is a race, not a religion. Obama is half Caucasian and half African-American, which in many Caucasian eyes, makes him all African-American.

Muslims, believe in Islam, which is a religion not a race. Obama believes in Christianity, not Islam. So that makes him a Christian.

Since you seem to believe in hate and violence, that would make you a Satanist.

You are to be pitied for not knowing the obvious difference between race and religion, and for being such a coward for not embracing God's diversity of race and religion.

If God wanted everything to be the same, there never would have been the 'big bang' to begin with.

Hey now - Satanists have

Hey now - Satanists have apologized for their role in helping to cook up and invent the Republicans - we should respect the Satanists contribution towards what spritual diversity we have.

I painted some cartoon on the cartoon

http://ccoaler.blogspot.com/2009/02/nypost-publishes-cartoon-that-depicts.html

"The media is so blatantly

"The media is so blatantly liberal that to suggest this was a racist cartoon somehow implies the liberal media has committed an act of treason against one of its own." ......????????..... The NY Post is owned by the same guys as Fox News, and usually is to the right of Fox News. The cartoonists is as conservative as they come, makes fun of gays & democrats every chance he gets. Grab a clue.

Sit Down And Shut Up

Satire is often not intended to be funny. Readers and others are sorely mistaken to assume satire, whether written, spoken or drawn, is to always be funny.

Satire targets human nature and our human nature is often not funny, not at all. Seems these days we humans spend most of our time stealing, swindling, raping, murdering and engaging in warfare.

When we are not busy effecting a Ponzi scheme, we are busy killing each other. Rarely, today, do we examine these issues of personal and societal responsibilities, which are rarely of a funny nature.

What I see going on is a bandwagon loaded up with victims, and a bandwagon loaded up with perpetrators, both engaging in an inane race to convince bystanders who is the better.

I am not a bystander. I am not about to waste time from my life cheering or booing these stringless yo-yos racing along to cross a finish line of stupidity. I am not interested in listening to alleged victims whine and cry nor interested in listening to alleged perpetrators huff and puff.

This chimpanzee cartoon does not target any one person nor racial group. This cartoon targets a broad spectrum of problems created by our human nature.

Keeping a 200 pound wild animal as a pet is absolute idiocy. Helping to contain a 200 pound wild animal is absolute idiocy. This stimulus package coming out of Capitol Hill is absolute idiocy. George Bush is an idiot. Barrack Obama is an idiot. Our California Governor Muscle Head is an idiot. Almost all of us are idiots.

Those pontificating this cartoon is racist in nature, are idiots. Those screaming this cartoon is not racist in nature, are idiots.

Satire in based in effecting subtle unique reactions from each person. None of us "see" quite the same satiric message. We see what our mind's eye directs us to see.

Why the heck do you people demand I think like you, regardless of your point of view? Who are you to dictate what I may think or may not think?

Each of us is responsible to deal with satire in an intelligent and mature fashion, and we are responsible to be tolerant of diversity in opinion, in satire.

Whining and crying self-made victims rasp my nerves. Those claiming authority on what is and what is not, really annoy me.

I say to all who are up in arms over this cartoon, either against or for this cartoon, I say, "Sit down and shut up."

I do not much cotton to idiots and this does seem everywhere I look, there stands an idiot, ranting about this and that. Sit down and shut up, already.

Satire is not always intended to be funny nor are my comments intended to be funny.

Okpulot Taha
Choctaw Nation

Let Freedom Ring.

Freedom of speech is a guarantee that every person has the opportunity to be heard. Silence gives a racist or rapist the opportunity to operate unmolested. But we must also have a well funded Justice Department that is always on the alert for violators of a person civil rights. It must be staffed by tens of thousands of our most liberal minded investigators. They should be given the freedom and time to dig deep and wide. Those depriving others of the right to: “Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness” must be dealt with quickly and harshly. Major civil right violators must be hung by the Justice Department in front of shopping malls. Enough Is Enough!!

Making a Monkey out of us all

If the Liberals had put out this kind of race slanted ,it would be on the news for 2 months.As much trouble as the USA is in right now ,it just blows my mind that some "goof ball" wants to bring this into the mix.I am convinced of one thing ,the far right NEO-CONS will say ,and do what ever they so desire ,to H### with who gets hurt.We have big,big problems ,and to be doing this is just plain stupid.

Congratulations, Right Wing Anonymous Coward!

You have violated the Revised Godwin's Law by using "Liberal", "Progressive", "Socialist" or "Communist" in a pejorative term in your post. Therefore, you have rendered all your arguments null and void for all time - in the same way YOU claim anyone referring to Right Wingers like you (truthfully) as "Nazis" do!

Can somebody explain to me why BuzzFlash is allowing anonymous postings now - and worse, using "BuzzFlash" as the default "Anonymous" name, thus implying these idiots somehow represent BuzzFlash?

I was wondering about that too, but from the other direction.

I was wondering why the racists don't identify themselves. Oh, I know. It's because the right are all cowards.

Rupe the dupe

Murdoch never would have published it if the cartoon was about a koala bear.

Racist Cartoon

I am anything but a proponent of political correctness, which is often used as a smokescreen in violation of the First Amendment to try and suppress thoughts and ideas. Nonetheless, the recent New York Post "cartoon" depicting President Obama as a monkey was blatantly racist. It was so far over the line that the line was just a dot. The people at that newspaper had to know that it was a racist cartoon and they ran it anyway. No apology can correct what the paper did and its cynical non-apology is a further insult.

Racist Cartoon

The cartoon wasn't about Obama. He didn't write the Stimulus Bill. Wake-up people.

wake up yourself

For many many years monkeys have been used by racists to depict African-Americans. A monkey with a banana was used by republicans during the campaign to depict Obama. Obama may not have written the stimulus bill but he was the one pushing it, he was the face of the bill.

Racist cartoon

Anybody who has any knowledge at all of the history of editorial cartoons in the United States will clearly see the blatancy in this cartoon. Those who choose to remain ignorant, insensitive, or racist will be mesmerized by how "clever" it is. The concept for this cartoon clearly arises from the nineteenth century. Perhaps that's why there are so many people rushing to defend it -- our education system is deeply rooted the nineteenth century. American socio-political awareness still has a very long way to go. I fear for the immediate future as well as that of our children.

Racist Cartoon

The media is so blatantly liberal that to suggest this was a racist cartoon somehow implies the liberal media has committed an act of treason against one of its own. Everyone in mainstream America knows the stimulus plan will not work. It’s too bad the police didn't shoot a jackass this week, because that is the type of animal that is synonymous with the authors of the stimulus bill.

You make a basic mistake.

You are under the belief that your fellow right-wing loons are "mainstream" America.

racist cartoon

The NY Post is liberal?? What is obvious is your ignorance. The NY Post is about as liberal as Fox News. Is your state governor going to refuse stimulus funding to help the unemployed, to fund education, to improve the infra-structure of this country?

Wow. This may be the most

Wow. This may be the most ignorant nonsense I've ever read. Anywhere.

The media is liberal = the NY Post is liberal.

That's terminally clueless.

addendum

"If" anyone was offended. Somewhere lies a shallow implication, "the hell with them", they're not our constituency, not our base, not our "true" believers. So to hell with what anybody dislikes about ruling-class journalism.

Fairness

All of us must accept the reality that Big Daddy is here to stay. It is impossible to keep order without a mediator and that is the job of Big Daddy. But we must make sure that Big Daddy has no favorites and distributes all goods and services fairly. There are those that have been getting the lions share and don’t want to give it up. But there is a new and fairer Big Daddy and he will leave no child behind.

new york post

I will no longer buy your paper ,nor will any of my friends.SURELY you know the history of this country and the treatment of black americans.Your paper has been around long enough to have seen and lived through those shameful times .And dont try to pretend that you dont know that black men have been ,looked upon as apelike.It was stupid and in bad taste ,as well as racist.There is nothing funny about a poor animal who was killed,he was tired of being caged and made to act as a human.Then to connect it the president,no way will you get away with this. .Other countries know .We brought the busses to a halt,.Opeaned up the schools ,and lunch counters,got the vote a holiday and many other things ,and its time to bring your paper to its SORRY demise.We as a country will destroy it self with our hatred of each other .And other countries cant wait,to scoop in and take the prize.We will not help you to do this, we will never as a people buy your paper again.

New York Post

I'm sure the Post could care less if you buy it or not. You probably haven't ever bought it in the first place. You didn't do nothing except whine. Your ancestors done everything for you. Afro-American people are the most racist group of people because if white people had a TV channel called WET instead of BET, White College Fund instead of Black College Fund, ya'll be calling us racist. Figure That!!!! Plus, everyone else earns their promotions and jobs including alot of Afro-Americans without complaining but most get selected because of Qouta's and Federal Government Requirements to select the less qualified because of race. OOPS. Is that a racist comment? TOO BAD....

NEW YORK POST

i agree that African-american is the most racist...i can even imagine how it would like if they are the majority in America...what happened in the past make them think that white are racist..

Who lnows?

They might grab you by the throat and force you to type grammatically correct English.

Now that a Golden Age of Science may be on the horizon...

Can we PLEASE stop referring to chimps as "monkeys"? They are NOT monkeys; they are Great Apes. Let's keep our orders, genuses and species straight as we celebrate science and drive oppressive religion back to the cave it came from.

Wait - think this through

WHY would we want to shut them down and shut them up? If we do such a thing, then racism goes back under a rock, anonymously. See, I'm glad that jackholes like Rush have a radio show. It shows us - and proves, without a shadow of a doubt - who the haters and the racists are. It gives us reason to stand against it. This is bigotry's public face: out in the open, unabashedly talking from their souls (no matter how dark a place that might be). Would you rather racism crawls under the rock of society again and permeates in a quiet, word of mouth way AGAIN? That is what we fought so hard against before -- that's simply generating more institutional racism. With papers like the Post out there, we can use them as a publicly humiliated example of what NOT to do and who NOT to be. I say: long live Murdoch and Limbaugh and Hannity and O'Reilly and their ilk. The hoods have come off necessarily, and we know who they are -- just make damn sure you never, ever give up the ghost, so to speak, of telling the world WHY what they say is so awful. -Bobby

news paper

As a black woman it really gets to me that our men have been so mistreated .My dad served this country ,and could not even get a decent job,when he got back.I JUST THINK THAT YOU HAVEto hit them in the pocket book to make a difference.They cant be embrassed,are you kidding!!Iam for freedom of the press and speach ,but we hold the last and mightiest,card which is our dollar.And they should not get ours.There are other news papers to read.

THEY ARE INCITING VIOLENCE!!!

That's why I want to shut these idiots down. Do you remember the assassinations of the 1960's? Well, I do. This is a like pouring gasoline on the flame of some very sick people out there, and that's all it takes. Read your history. Enough said!!!

Racist Comic

That is unquestionably a racist cartoon. As a caucasian American who neither voted for Obama nor McCain, and a skeptic of any "news story" the media demands our distracted focus upon, I can clearly see that a chimp who attacked a lady, has nothing to do with this piece of trash. What we should all be asking ourselves is, while this non-story is being waved in our faces, what is really happening in the world that the media wishes to keep us from paying attention to?