Dave Lindorff: Is America a Sick Country or What?
You see, here's the thing. When you hear about the sick, twisted things that America's torturers have been doing, courtesy of President George W. Bush and Vice President Darth Cheney, you have to remember that the U.S. military and the CIA were not really all that reliable when it came to picking up the real terrorists. In fact, their batting average was pretty lousy.
According to even the Pentagon's own reckoning, for example, probably 85% of the captives being held at Guantanamo over the past eight years were not terrorists at all, and a fair number -- probably the majority -- weren't even fighting anyone when they were captured. I'm sure that the averages at Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan, or at the secret prison in Iraq are no better. The military was offering bounties in Iraq and Afghanistan for alleged terrorists, you see, and probably still is, but in both of those lawless, tribal countries, many people have used the offer to settle old feuds, turning in people they wanted to punish or dispose of, and many others just turned in random people to get the reward money.
Remember this when you hear about torture tactics that we are learning were used by our side -- things that make waterboarding sound like a walk in the park. We're now getting confirmation of things that we journalists were hearing rumors of earlier: faked executions using blanks, faked executions in neighboring rooms, followed by threats of the same to a person who had just heard the screams and a shot in the cell next to him, threats with an electric drill, and now perhaps the worst yet -- the threat to kill a captive's children. And of course there is the already disclosed case of a captive who had his genitals cut with a razor, and generous use of tasers in places on the body designed to cause maximum pain. That, and of course there are a lot raped captives (including young boys), and a lot of bodies yet to be dug up of captives who were simply killed during torture.
We've got a litany of horror and abuse here that sounds like the worst kind of stories that used to come out of Saddam Hussein's Iraq, or the Argentine Junta, or Idi Amin's Uganda. About the only thing missing is word that the military and CIA torturers were eating their victims, or feeding them their own genitals, but who knows? Maybe we'll get there yet. It's hard at this point to rule anything out.
What has become of the U.S.? We started out the victims of an attack in 2001, with the whole world rallying to our side, and within a matter of weeks, our government, acting in our name, had secretly embarked on a wholly unnecessary and totally criminal descent into the barbarity of Middle Ages.
And now? The new administration has claimed to have put a stop to the atrocities, but it remains adamant that it is not going to root out the evil that was already done to hundreds, perhaps thousands of people.
President Barack Obama says he does not want to look back at any crimes that were committed. He wants to go "forward." This is not the voice of justice, though. This is the voice of political gutlessness and of big power exceptionalism. The same America that demands the prosecution of war criminals in little countries such as Cambodia or Serbia or Sudan, considers itself exempt from criminal liability for its own crimes.
Attorney General Eric Holder Attorney General Eric Holder says he's appointing a special prosecutor, John Durham, to investigate cases where CIA or private contract torturers "overstepped" the rules set by the White House and Justice Department, but he has said he will not allow the investigation to go beyond that to pursue the people who enabled those acts of torture -- people such as Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld who personally instructed torturers in Afghanistan to "take the gloves off" in one case, or Assistant Attorney Generals John Yoo and Jay Baybee (now a federal judge), who ruled that anything short of the destruction of bodily organs or of a pain level equivalent to death was okay. Nor will he allow any investigation to look at acts of torture that were authorized, such as waterboarding, if they had the sanction of the Bush/Cheney White House.
This position taken by the new administration should sicken us all. Worse, it should be broadly condemned, because if the descent into barbarity which occurred with the highest White House sanction is not investigated thoroughly, and punished fully, there is no way we can say it will not happen again. In fact, it's safe to say that it will happen again, the next time another charlatan gets into office and uses fear to blind the American people to all that is right and decent, and to the importance of maintaining the rule of law.
I know there are terrible things happening right now that demand our attention and action -- an escalating, endless war in Afghanistan that increasingly resembles Vietnam in 1966 or 1967, a presidential cave-in on health care reform, a sellout on real action against climate change, and on and on -- but this particular crime -- the crime of failing to act to punish violations of the Geneva Conventions on treatment of prisoners of war, which is being committed today by the Obama Administration -- is so obscene, so directly in our faces, and is such a stain on the whole nation, that it demands action.
We will probably never know how many innocent lives have been destroyed by America's eight years of officially sanctioned torture, but we can at least see to it that the people who sanctioned it, and not just those who engaged in it (and that goes right up through the chain of command to the Commander in Chief and to the real power behind the throne, Dick Cheney), are put in the dock such as the criminals at Nuremberg, to face the charge of war crimes and crimes against humanity.
As the citizens of what we call a democracy, we can demand nothing less.
DAVE LINDORFF is a Philadelphia-area journalist. His latest book is "The Case for Impeachment" (St. Martin's Press, 2006). His work is available at www.thiscantbehappening.net.
- Login or register to post comments
- Printer-friendly version
Buzz this on Buzzflash.net




Technorati Tags:
So what do you propose to do about it all?
March up and down Pennsylvania Avenue with giant puppets?
Hold a mass "We'll Hold Our Breath Until Our Faces Turn Blue" sit-in on the Washington, D.C. Mall?
Let's all vote for honest Green Party candidates in 2010 so the Republicans can take back both Houses of Congress. That'll show Obama!
Please, the change of administration is only...what?...a little over eight months? Let's see, except for four years of Jimmy Carter (history's great villain) and eight years of Bill Clinton, six of those years with a Republican majority in both Houses of Congress, anti-government Republicans have pretty much had their way with the administrative side of government since 1969! The administrative side of federal government is riddled with highly placed, career Republican appointees whom actively sabotage their own agencies. That's not paranoia talking. I've seen it!
You may be dismayed at the pace of Holder's criminal investigation of Bush/Cheney torture, but, duh, criminal investigations do take time! It make take years to make a watertight case against Cheney, Yoo and Baybee.
So what do you propose? Tumbrels and guillotines?
ET Spoon
_How_ do we "demand" nothing less?
Let's face it. Amiericans are beaten masochists. A candyland for sadists.
You betch'a. Is this
You betch'a. Is this something new like when they discovered gold in California? Heh, let's not be fooled. This has been going on for years and decades...there is the School of the Americas specializing in helping our "friends" perfect their technics.
How many dead in South America and all the other contintents where we pitch our tents..and these ungrateful people hate us for our freedom. Just wait until they get a taste of our exported democracy. That will shut them up!
It is more and more as though being cut off from the world by two oceans is a sort of solitary confinement with the loud blasting voices of Fox, Limbaugh, O'Reilly, Beck non stop driving us crazy, the exact same methods used on detainees. Guess what, it works! People go mad, become pawns in the hands of their "interrogators." screaming, "Don't let them kill Grandma, the death book," they will say whatever their handlers want them to say.
There is nothing new in all this but the means to spread it are like none we have ever known.
Druthers
A good laugh
You gotta smirk, at least, at those who claim the U.S. used to have finer values. Tell that to the Nez Perce, or the Filipinos, or, for that matter, the native Hawaiians. A country with a Constitution institutionalizing predatory capitalism, based on genocide and slavery, and grown on the exploitation of littler, browner people worldwide cannot claim to EVER have had any human values.
Is America a Sick Country or What?
Is a criminal sick, a murderer, a thief, a rapist, a deserter, a liar/purjurer, a company who takes your money, and then cuts off your healthcare, or takes your retirement funds and gives them to the same sons of bitches who destroyed the company to begin with?
Goddammit All To Hell!!!! How many buckets of shit do you need to make a Shit Sandwich? I am so very Fucking Tired of what is going on in the country of my birth. I am a 71 year old retired Navy Chief Petty Officer, and I DO NOT ABIDE FOOLS or IDIOTS!!!!
What the Fuck has happened ;to Common Sense and Decency? Has the country stooped so low that it kneels to shoddy authoritian rule, and fundamentalist dogma? Does the wishes of the very rich very minority shitbags that you worship mean that much, where you would allow your freedoms and rights, Yes motherfuckers!!!! Those very same rights and freedoms that I spent 20+ years working for shit wages and putting up with civilians shitting in my corn flakes because I was a military man, a sailor, and thereby less valuable than the piece of shit who never served and leeched off of our sweat, blood and tears.. I still believe in the Constitution and Bill Of Rights, I still have faith in the Geneva Conventions. I honor all who still feel the same way, as I took an Oath to Defend that very same Document (The Constitution) against ALL enemys, foreign and domestic.... I took that same oath every time I re enlisted. I was proud to do so, I never took it on a Bible or any other book, I took the Oath ON MY HONOR...... I was willing to gladly give my life for that Document that Herr George W. Bush called a Goddamn Piece Of Paper. Now you tell me, what kind of Officer in the United States Military let alone the President of the United States of America would make a statement like that?
No, I am sorry to say, that I lost all respect for the government of the country of my birth and back when an empty suit by the name of Ronald Reagan was elected, I immigrated to Tahiti, and have been a French Citizen since 1986. I have been watching the country of my birth in a death spiral, and the way things are looking, I will probably outlive the country of my birth. Oh, you may very well still be called the United Stated, but i don't think that you will be a democracy, or a democratic republic.
I can no longer make excuses for you, I have drifted too far apart from what the government is doing today, against the majorities wishes. A country that will not investigate or charge known criminals with the treasonous acts we know that they performed or aided and abetted? A country who aids in the overthrow of other governments and captures, jails, and tortures innocent people. A country that tortures children, and jails others for life over petty crimes and lets those who destroy the lives of hundreds of thousand of others go free, or even gives them medals and honors in recognition of their perfidies. I so much would like to see the america that I loved turn the corner and get back on track.... I had huge hopes that President Obama would be the one to lead the country out of the darkness, but it looks like he has been either bought and paid for, or was lying to all of us from the beginning...
One thing for sure, if anyone in my family or my wife's family were treated like those who were held and are still being held in your off shore prisons etc... And they were being treated like these same people, There would be some killing going on, and I wouldn't care if they were tourists, government employees or just plain old repigs..... I would be doing my thing to get even for my family.... You better fucking believe that! If it were me or my family that were being wronged, I wouldn't be trying to get even, I would be saying it's payback time and there is the fucking intrest payment for the first payment and there are a lifetime more to come...
One thing is for sure, I will never be returning..... I value my liberty and freedoms too much to spend time in a Fascist state, and if you don't think you're Fascist, look at who is controlling your government and news etc.....
Something that suprises the hell out of me is the fact that I am not seeing thousands of Viet Nam Vets on the streets, or other vets for that matter...... I think that you have grown soft and lazy, and also have become selfish and self centered... you think more of your individual selves than you do of others... You are loosing your humanity and along with it your tolerance for the beliefs and ideas of others... You are returning to a state of minority totalitarian rule and I want NO Part of that..
Kenneth R. Jackson
CPO USN Ret
French and Goddam Proud
Tahiti?
I imagine a lot of Americans are looking for an escape. I agree that this country has been infected with a kind of capitalist fascist rot that is destroying the tree of liberty. It's a fight or flight situation.
THE key to what has happened to America over the past 40 years..
The key to what has happened in America over the past 40 years is detailed in author Michael Lind's book, "Made in Texas: George W. Bush and the SOUTHERN TAKEOVER of AMERICAN POLITICS." (Lind has been interviewed several times on Buzzflash- http://www.buzzflash.com/interviews/03/03/20_lind.html
http://www.amazon.com/Made-Texas-Southern-Takeover-American/dp/0465041213
Lind explains that, under Cheney & Bush's STOLEN ELECTION of 2000, the Neo-CONFEDERATE AGENDA has come to DOMINATE American politics (and thus POWER), just as the SEGREGATIONIST SENATORS DOMINATED the US Senate, until President Lyndon Johnson BROKE the Southern, Segregationist FILIBUSTER in 1964.
Despite Johnson's tremendous legislative skills (Johnson had been the Senate Majority Leader, so effective at arm-twisting & party-line enforcement that he was considered THE DICTATOR of the Senate), it took everything Johnson knew about politics, and the new "TV" images of Civil Rights protesters being attacked by dogs & beaten by cops, and the skillful PR use of, & public sympathy for "President Kennedy DIED FIGHTING FOR FREEDOM" (the "myth of Camelot"), for Johnson to lead the Democratic (with help from Moderate Republicans) to overturn the Southern, Segregationist CONTROL of Congress.
Fast forward to 1990s, President Clinton's NARCISSISM and corporate (DLC) "Republican lite" character (and Al Gore's even MORE BEFFUDLED sense of "leadeship") ALLOWED the Bush-Cheney Republicans to STEAL the election of 2000, and REASSERT the neo-CONFEDERATE AGENDA...with more than a little help from the CORPORATE DEMOCRATS, who, for example, voted for BUSH's TAX-CUTS FOR RICH and other signature Right-Wing "loot the peons, enrich the masters" policies, right out of the neo-Confederate playbook.
But here's the important part: While Mr. Lind explains THE ALLIANCE between the Northeast Big Finance, Ivy League, NY/DC/Chicago and other corporate Democrat academic/intellectual "Neo-Cons" with the Radical Right Republican anti-intellectual agenda, Lind falls short in realizing that the NEO-CONS are now the DOMINATE PARTNER in the Neo-Con/neo-Confederate alliance.
The GOLDMAN SACHS NEO-CONS have CLEARLY TAKEN OVER the OBAMA WHITE HOUSE, and much of the "Democrat" Party - and even though back in 2002 Michael Lind spelled out that the Neo-Con agenda is IDENTICAL WITH the Neo-Confederate ideology, even today, MOST AMERICANS have NO IDEA that the Democrats are now "OWNED" by the Goldman-Sachs/AIPAC/Likudnik Neo-Cons.... WHO ARE EVERY BIT as FAR TO THE "RIGHT" as the blatantly would-be segregationists neo-Confederates!
Here's Lind's Feb. 2002 update (in "The Daily Beast") "The SOUTH vs OBAMA" - http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-stories/2009-01-29/the-south-rises-again/ - Lind fails to understand that OBAMA is EMPOWERING "the Southern reactionaires", because Obama has STACKED his White House with Neo-Cons like pro-war Rahm Emanuel & the Golddamn-Sachs bankers, WHO ARE actually ALLIED WITH that radical-right-wing neo-Confed agenda!!
With the American press/media in-the-tank for the corporate right-wing agenda, Americans don't realize that they are being WHIPSAWED between the REPUBLICAN version of the Right-Wing agenda, and the "Democrat" Neo-Con/Likudnik/Goldamn-Sachs VERSION OF SAME !!
-----------------------------------------------
(Here's the proof of the above: The GRAMM-LEACH-BLILEY Act of 1999 was a FINANCIAL DEREGULATION ATROCITY authored by uber- RIGHT-WING REPUBLICANS PHIL GRAMM, Jim Leach, and Tom Bliley. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gramm-Leach-Bliley_Act
This ATROCITY was SUPPORTED by Clinton "Democrat" Treasury Secretaries ROBERT RUBIN and LAWRENCE SUMMERS! - AS WAS the similar "Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodity_Futures_Modernization_Act_of_2000 which created the so-called "ENRON Accounting Loophole" - the loophole which allowed finance companies to WRITE HUGE INSURANCE CONTRACTS as "stock option derivatives" (the infamous "credit DEFAULT swaps" - effectively AN INSURANCE CONTRACT against a loan DEFAULT) - thereby BYPASSING decades worth of strict insurance rules!!
Robert Rubin, Lawrence Summers, Timmy Geithner, and the ENTIRE Goldman-Sachs crew (including President BUSH's "loot the Treasury" Treasury Secretary, HANK PAULSON) were all in support of the above Financial DEREGULATION atrocities! Hank Paulson, like Robert Rubin, had been a CHAIRMAN of Goldman Sachs.
The Clinton/Obama/DLC "Democrats" KEEP PRETENDING that you can vote for and support THE MOST RIGHT-WING of Republican legislation (in this case, Financial DEREGULATION that GUTTED SEVEN DECADES of financial oversight) - and still call yourself "Democratic". IF you VOTE to support RIGHT-WING REPUBLICAN legislation, THAT MAKES YOU a RIGHT-WING REPUBLICAN!!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Rubin
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Summers
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timothy_Geithner
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goldman_Sachs
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Paulson
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phil_Gramm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wendy_Lee_Gramm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enron_loophole
The Last Puzzle Piece
Yeah, Dave is correct, but he didn't explicitly state what he hinted: Eric Holder is a COWARLY PUSSY who (for whatever insignificant reason) won't take on the lawless Republicrooks. For that matter, same goes for Obama, Reid, Pelosi, and most of the Demowimp politicos. This, despite the numerous witch-hunts the Dems have been subjected to by Republicrooks!
Alas, let us not forget all that transpired during the Bad Old Days from 2001 to 2006:
-- Election fraud and outright theft on so many levels;
-- Failure to prevent the 2001 hijackings through incredibly gross incompetence, then using that tragedy as a terror weapon to bash the American sheeple over the head, while demonizing those who correctly refused to kowtow to this insanity;
-- Exposure of a CIA operative for tawdry political revenge, against a whistleblower who dared to call the top-end Republicrooks on their series of BIG LIES;
-- the non-existant Iraqi WMDs, and the non-existant Iraqi ties to bin_Laden, which the two top tyrants and their various bogeymen insisted were there;
-- the phony "Mission Accomplished" stunt, arranged by the W.H., who then lied about arranging it;
-- Raising of the ridiculous color-coded "terror threat level" at many points in 2004, just when it appeared Kerry-Edwards was getting ahead of Smirky W. Fuck-Up in the polls;
-- In 2005, most of a major American city is allowed to wash away, while an uncaring tyranny does virtually nothing before, during, and after the storm, save for flyovers and photo-ops;
-- Illegal wiretapping in a widespread and systematic way, which amounted to nothing more than spying and snooping on honest people (mainly those who stood in opposition to Republicrook war policy);
-- And of course, the aforementioned torture program, Abu Ghirab, Gitmo, other secret camps, etc.;
-- In addition to despicable Dick and clueless George, a seemingly endless series of Who's Who in human history's greatest thugs: Ashcroft, Ridge, Rove, Libby, Rice, Powell, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz, Feith, Addington, Gonzalez.
What is the most saddening here is that, after over 230 years as a nation, we are left with such dismal political choice. Republicrooks won't respect any law, and Demowimps won't stand up for any principle. If only the 90 or 100 million or so among us who don't vote would get off their asses and support a Green or honest Libertarian (not Bob Barr, the ex-Rethuglican), they would kick the shit out of both the Republicrooks and the Demowimps..... However, progressives must begin to realize that they have no future inside the Democratic Party, which talks about "law and order" yet won't enforce it, which gives lip service to affordable health care for all but then makes deals with Big Pharma and gives the discredited Republicrooks a seat at the table, and a president who campaigned on (and stated repeatedly) a promise to get out of Iraq within 16 months, but then somehow that became 19 months with a "security force" still there of at least 50,000 American troops (WTF!!?), and now it's something like we'll be out by the end of 2011.
Well, I have a better idea: lets get rid of both major political parties by the end of 2011!
The Obama Problem
Not only is our new president wrong, Nadler thinks he's broken the law. He claims our participation in treaties against torture compel the US to prosecute domestic torturers. You can toss a little obstruction of justice on top of that as Obama is actively blocking civil suits involving torture. Obama's use of drones and expansion of the war in Afghanistan (alleging the Taliban are responsible for 9-11--is there any Middle Eastern country our leaders haven't accused of being in on 9-11?) and fresh accusations of torture on his watch are indications that we may have another serial criminal in the White House. Time for a new impeachment movement? Not that Biden any better.
Carol DW
We need to call it what it is... GESTAPO torture...
Dave is exactly correct: many, many, many prisoners have been killed - MURDERED - in US custody undergoing torture.
(In fact, this is very "old news" - way back in the glory days of the US/Northern Alliance victories over Taliban in late 2002, CIA agent MIKE SPANN was videotapped (and played on US network TV) telling a bound, seated, and helpless "American Taliban" captive John Walker Lindh, "IF YOU DON'T TALK, YOU WILL BE KILLED." Ironically, it was Spann, not Lindh, who was killed in a prison insurrection at Masari-al Shariff just a few days later at (a prisoner uprising some observers have suggested the CIA INSTIGATED, to GIVE THEM AN EXCUSE to have their Northern Alliance warlords MASSACRE the captured Taliban prisoners... which happened a few days later.)
For years now, the Neo-Cons who DOMINATE the US press & media - starting with the NY TIMES, the WASHINGTON POST, Time/Warner/CNN, and FOX 'news' - have been able to blur and fuzzy this basic, cruel reality with their various whines, rationalizations, and (worst of all) blatant JUSTIFICATIONS and ENDORSEMENTS.
(Just as Cheney, Rumsfeld, & the Bush Sr. Republicans were able, with complicity of US corporate media, to WHITEWASH THEIR SUPPORT for SADDAM HUSSEIN's brutal, genocidal regime, ALL THROUGH the 1980s Iran-Iraq war years.)
Here's Robt. Parry (the great investigative journalist BLACKBALLED by NY/DC corporate media & the Washington Post and forced into journalistic Sieberia, FOR HAVING the TEMERITY TO BREAK the IRAN-CONTRA story in the 1980s) comments on the obvious -
"The Washington Post is a Neo-Con propaganda sheet" -
http://www.consortiumnews.com/2009/031509.html
These Neo-Con rags have been trying to have it BOTH ways: SCORN, CONDEMN, and DEMONIZE Saddam Hussein, the Iran Ayatollahs, the Taliban, the Russians, and other "evil doers" for their torture & dictatorship regimes... WHILE the Neo-Cons APPROVE OF GESTAPO TORTURE by their ALLIES, INCLUDING the SAUDIS, the Egyptians... and OUR OWN CIA and "mercenaries" in the employ of the US government?!!
IF all the "liberal" web-sites and authors out there ALWAYS USED THE WORD "GESTAPO" in front of "Torture", it would FORCE the "DEMOCRAT" Party, the corporate "Major Media", and the US government to NO LONGER BE ABLE TO WAFFLE back and forth across the "torture is evil/torture is necessary" line. And it might SHAME the NY Times & WashPost to, well, stop acting like Geobbels junior.
The man
behind the curtain pulls the levels of power. GW Bush was Poppy Bush's heir to the shadow government (the real government) Barak Obama couldn't do anything about it if he wanted to. All presidents are political brands. All brands are esstentialy political product front men. Do you prefer Coke or Pepsi?
USA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
USA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!