Get FREE BuzzFlash News Alerts

Email:  

We need to start seeing Muslim citizens as regular Americans

The cast from the CBC show "Little Mosque on the Prairie," a show that tries to enlighten viewers on the world of Muslims. An American version will appear soon on FOX.

BE-ELECTED
by Chad Rubel

In World War II, we had three major enemies: Germany, Italy, and Japan. Guess which one's fellow people we primarily put into internment camps during the war. If you guessed the non-European country (Japan), you get a gold star. (Yes, we also interned German-Americans and Italian-Americans, but not nearly to the extent of the Japanese-Americans.)

The people of Japanese descent were no more of a threat to the American people in the 1940s than the American Muslims of the 21st Century. And yet, instead of learning from the horrors of the Japanese internment camps, our ignorance rolls on.

As a kid, I remember seeing horrible Japanese caricatures in Looney Tunes cartoons. Two troubling examples are "Bugs Bunny Nips the Nips" and "Tokio Jokio."

We were at war with the Japanese for just under 4 years. But the "war on terror" continues, which is not so good news for Muslims who live in the United States. True, we aren't interning them in camps, so we did learn that lesson. But the discrimination continues.

A volunteer for the Barack Obama campaign, citing politics as the reason, withdrew an invitation to two Muslims in head scarves from appearing behind the Democratic presidential candidate for the television cameras in Detroit.

The Obama campaign quickly apologized for the volunteer's actions, and also for another volunteer who reportedly told a Muslim supporter she could participate only if she removed her scarf. And it should be pointed out that Obama has appeared on several occasions with Muslims, and the day after the Monday incident in Detroit, Obama was photographed with a group of supporters that included a woman wearing a scarf.

The fact that this story happened in Detroit is even worse, since nearby Dearborn has traditionally had the most Arabs per capita of any U.S. city. In the 2000 Census, Arab Americans comprised 30% of Dearborn's population, and this doesn't include numerous Iraqi immigrants who have arrived since the Iraq war began. And the majority of more recent Arab immigrants have been Muslims.

The element of discrimination against Muslims also has a gender bias. A male Muslim can stand behind in a crowd, and not be an issue. But the head scarf, or hijab, or more extensive covering makes Muslim women more identifiable.

If there were an Institute of Irony, they would fully support having a presidential candidate in 2008 with a Muslim sounding name while we have this ongoing battle in this "war on terror" where every potential person who looks like the people who did horrible things to us might be seen as an "enemy."

Everybody in the world can be our enemy or can be our friend. It doesn't matter if they dress in lederhosen, hijabs, yarmulkes, or even like a Canadian lumberjack. Our colleague Dave Lindorff points out that we have no enemies, only countries where we disagree.

There might be a sliver of hope. FOX has announced an American version of the CBC show "Little Mosque on the Prairie," which bills itself as "small town Canada with a Muslim twist." The show focuses on the Muslim community in the fictional prairie town of Mercy, Saskatchewan. The two seasons of the program have received critical acclaim within Canada and notice from outside the country as well.

At some point, we finally figured out that the Japanese citizens weren't out to get us. So at what point will we reach the point where Muslim citizens can be treated normal, or whatever passes for normal in U.S. society.

Will it be when Muslims in hijabs stand behind the Republican candidate? Will it be when the American version of "Little Mosque on the Prairie" hits its 4th season? Tell us when you think life will return to normal for Muslim citizens in the U.S.?


Not just the Japanese

Yes, German-Americans and Italian-Americans were also interned, but not nearly to the extent of Japanese-Americans. The hostility toward the Japanese was much higher. The story now reflects that better.

Not just the Japanese....injustice is injustice

CrystalCity1945 A former internee therein!

In any event injustice is injustice.

And with your comment are you saying that if we had interned German Americans and Italian Americans to the same extent as Japanese Americans..then the internment would have been just, i.e., fair? What is your point?

And do you know that hostility was much greater toward Japanese Americans?

Who was interned?--

CrystalCity1945 A former internee therein!

Chad you got it wrong. German Americans, Italian Americans were also interned in the U.S. during World War II. As a matter of fact many of the European American internees were in the same camps as the Japanese American internees.

You have a chance to learn the true history of internment by visiting: http://www.foitimes.com

"Errors, like straw, on the surface flow, if you want pearls, you must dive below." Unknown

I'm astounded

I can't believe you posted this. There are enough questions to be asked about this story to fill several container ships. I posted about 20 elsewhere, but I'll just ask one here: How did this tiny event go national. These people were plants, and it was made to happen. It was a win-win situation. If they got seats behind the podium, that pic would go out. If they didn't this story would go out. Because of the nauseating, knee-jerk PC of many on the left, a minority will instantly be believed and fawned over. If these women were obese, teet-missing evangelicals, no one would on the left be talking about it.

They were not Obama supporters

Obama supporters and Muslims know a lot of voters think he is Muslim and the smears the repugs are doing. A real Obama supporter would not have wanted to sit behind him in Muslim dress.

Damn Right

It's common sense. Don't let misguided political correctness put McStain in the white house.

Japanese/Arab/Muslim Solidarity

Chad, If you are reading here, would like to let you know about something you may not be aware of possibly. Your article is GREAT and coincidentally brings up the comparison between the Japanese and current all-out prejudice against Muslims (Arabs also at large BTW). After 911, the Japanese community realized VERY quickly that the reaction to 911 would cause a backlash here in the US towards Muslims here. So, they made a concerted effort to reach out to that community. Many Japanese organizations formed committees to do this and the relationship has grown quite strong since. You mentioned that Muslims have not been interred like the Japanese were. In April, after much preparation and coordination, Japanese Americans here in California who have been making an annual pilgrimage to Manzanar for 39 years made that pilgrimage this year with a large group of Muslims. CAIR SoCal took up more than 100 Muslims, and CAIR in Northern California also took a smaller contingency. Prior to the trip, NCRR LA (Nikkei Civil Rights and Redress) presented five programs in local mosques about the Japanese internment experience. The pilgrimage together was a TOTAL success. This year not only Japanese participated in the programming, but also CAIR LA did as well. You can read about it by googling Manzanar Committee, also link to their blog. Here is the closing song from the program in April http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t5ihTvI3MzQ I really enjoyed reading your article Chad!

Islamophobia is here

This is another instance of Islamophobia. But not simply at the working level, at the political level. Obama has apologized for this incident. I am a Muslim born, raised, and educated in America. I am now a professional working very hard and getting promotions and awards within my department. Not sure if I was an outsider before, but at least I felt like one. All those in my organization now consider me "normal" or at least one of them. To the point now where I get invited to private events or outings with the fellas. I hope that one day, like this article says, all Muslim citizen's will be considered regular Americans.

Not soon

Our military culture is teaching hatred. The Christian Right are teaching hatred. And the vilest sort of hatred speech on the public airwaves is not curtailed in any way. This is being ingrained into our culture, much of it deliberately. This is how fascism works. Pat Williams