Memo to Palin: Fruit Fly Researchers Receive Nobel Prize for Medicine for Advancing the Understanding of Birth Defects in Humans
A BUZZFLASH READER CONTRIBUTION
by Kathy E. Mitchell, Ph.D., Biophysicist
by Kathy E. Mitchell, Ph.D., Biophysicist
"This is the most mindless, ignorant, uninformed comment that we have seen from Governor Palin so far, and there's been a lot of competition for that prize." - Richard Wolfe, Newsweek
Memo To Palin: Fruit Fly Researchers Receive Nobel Prize for Medicine for Advancing the Understanding of Birth Defects in Humans
http://www.accessexcellence.org...nob.gif
NOBEL PRIZE FOR GENETICS OF DEVELOPMENT 1995 STOCKHOLM, Sweden - Three biologists have been awarded the Nobel Prize in Medicine for their pioneering work on the genetic control of embryonic development. The researchers work with the Drosophila melanogaster fruit fly provided key information on factors influencing human embryology and birth defects. The recipients of this year's prize are Drs. Edward Lewis, of the California Institute of Technology; Christiane Nuesslein-Volhard, of Germany's Max-Planck Institute; and Eric Wieschaus, at Princeton. Each of the three were involved in the early research to find the genes controlling development of the Drosophila fruit fly.
The fruit fly, now a standard model in genetic research, is an ideal research animal since it develops from fertilized egg to embryo within nine days. "Most of the genes studied by Nuesslein-Volhard, Wieschaus and Lewis have important functions during the early development of the human embryo. It is likely that mutations in such important genes are responsible for some of the early, spontaneous abortions that occur in man, and for some of the about 40 percent of the congenital malformations that develop due to unknown reasons,'' according to a statement from Sweden's Karolinska Institute.
http://www.accessexcellence.org/WN/SUA06/aenobmed.php
http://joe.endocrinology-journals.org/content/vol191...gif
When Palin speaks in a mocking tone about the wasteful spending of taxpayer dollars to study "fruit flies", she shows her complete ignorance about biomedical research and the significance of “flies” as they are fondly referred to by geneticists.
Scientists rely on model organisms like Drosophila (fruit flies) and C. elegans (a nematode worm or just a “worm” to a geneticist) to study the molecular basis of biological processes and disease. The knowledge gained about disease processes and the function of proteins like potassium channels which play an essential role in the function of the heart have helped to develop better, safer drugs.
The major safety factor that causes a drug to be withdrawn from the market or its further study to be terminated during drug development is the effects of that drug on a potassium channel that was originally identified in fruit flies, the ether-a-go-go protein. The human counterpart to this potassium channel plays a key role in the rhythmic contractions of the heart. Many drugs, particularly antihistamines, block this potassium channel resulting in fatal arrhythmias. Unfortunately, in some cases, these potentially fatal drug interactions were not known until after the drug had been placed on the market and used in people that resulted in numerous deaths.
This is just one example of how the study of fruit flies and other model organisms has given scientists the knowledge and tools to advance our understanding of biological processes that result in human disease. Even now, in the laboratories of world-renowned geneticists who study flies, research is underway to further our understanding of how chromosome pairs split apart during maturation of the ovum (or egg) and how this process can go awry resulting in diseases like Downs syndrome. Trig, maybe when you grow up you can explain all of this science stuff to your mom.
Kathy E. Mitchell, Ph.D., Biophysicist mom (of five), stem cell biologist with lip stick
Columbia MD
A BUZZFLASH READER CONTRIBUTION
»
- Login or register to post comments
- Printer-friendly version

So it's like entrapping a
So it's like entrapping a mouse with more cheeses. Really, the corporate and bureaucracy system are the most dangerous area to make money. hammock
gege
Memo to Palin
The price of rent is depend
The price of rent is depend on the type of the car that you want. It just about prestige of rich people. classified |ads|tempurpedic mattress
Drosophila
One of the reasons Drosophila (fruit flies) has been heavily studied is because of an anomaly in its salivary glands. In the salivary glands of Drosophila, chromosomes replicate hundreds of times with cell division. In the days before DNA amplification (only a few decades ago) Drosophila salivary glands were about the only way of getting enough DNA to study.
The other reason is that with such a short lifespan, cross-breeding and induced mutations (by, for example, radiation) were easy to study compared to longer-live species.
None of this matters to Palin, who is ANTI-SCIENCE - as are all fundies. Science encompasses biology. Biology encompasses evolution. Evolution, as European biologists (such as Dawkins) happily admit but US biologists (such as Gould) will not admit (because it won't go down well with the fundies) not only eliminates the need for Gawd as an explanation for life on Earth but makes Gawd an exceedingl unlikely proposition.
Fundies hate Darwinism. Fortunately, so-called Intelligent Design can be used tor prove them wrong.
ID is rebadged creationism to try to sneak it past the Supremes. But ID allows that some little green alien in a flying saucer visited Earth and created life. However, that little green alien is too "irreducably complex" (an ID phrase) to have evolved. So the LGA must have been created by a little red alien. Which must have been created by a little blue alien. Infinite regress!
At some point, our little taupe alien must have arisen through evolution or have been created by God. And if you're willing to invoke either explanation for the LTA you can use Occam's razor to use that explanation for life on Earth. So ID is inherently dishonest, because the alien theory is untenable.
But Gawd is far more complex than a man. Man is created in Gawd's image but Gawd is omniscient, omnipresent and answers prayers. Gawd is too complex to have arisen by chance. So Gawd must have been created by Super Gawd. And Super Gawd must have been created by Hyper Gawd. And Hyper Gawd must have been created by Ultra Gawd. Infinite regress!
Evolution explains how complex lifeforms arise from simpler lifeforms. The ID argument of "irreducible complexity" boils down to "I can't see how you could get from A to B." In EVERY case that irreducible complexity has been claimed, biologists have proposed plausible routes from A to B. I suspect that many claims of irreducible complexity are made not from ignorance but from knowledge of what has not yet been explained.
The only FLY palin understands...
Palin Wins Non Nobel Prize