Greg Palast: Hurricane George: How the White House Drowned New Orleans
A BUZZFLASH GUEST CONTRIBUTION
by Greg Palast
[Thursday, August 23] It's been two years. And America's media is about to have another tear-gasm over New Orleans. Maybe Anderson Cooper will weep again. The big networks will float into the moldering corpse of the city and give you uplifting stories about rebuilding and hope.
Now, let's cut through the crybaby crap. Here's what happened two years ago -- and what's happening now. This is what an inside source told me. And it makes me sick:
"By midnight on Monday, the White House knew. Monday night I was at the state Emergency Operations Center and nobody was aware that the levees had breeched. Nobody."
The charge is devastating: That, on August 29, 2005, the White House withheld from the state police the information that New Orleans was about to flood. From almost any other source, I would not have believed it. But this was not just any source. The whistleblower is Dr. Ivor van Heerden, deputy director of the Louisiana State University Hurricane Center, the chief technician advising the state on saving lives during Katrina.
I'd come to van Heerden about another matter, but in our talks, it was clear he had something he wanted to say, and it was a big one. He charged that the White House, FEMA, and the Army Corps hid, for critical hours, their discovery that the levees surrounding New Orleans were cracking, about to burst and drown the city.
Understand that Katrina never hit New Orleans. The hurricane swung east of the city, so the state evacuation directors assumed New Orleans was now safe -- and evacuation could slow while emergency efforts moved east with the storm.
But unknown to the state, in those crucial hours on Monday, the federal government's helicopters had filmed the cracks that would become walls of death by Tuesday.
Van Heerden revealed: "FEMA knew at 11 o'clock on Monday that the levees had breeched. At 2 p.m., they flew over the 17th Street Canal and took video of the breech."
Question: "So the White House wouldn't tell you the levees had breeched?"
Dr. Van Heerden: "They didn't tell anybody."
Question: "And you're at the Emergency Center.'
Dr. Van Heerden: "I mean nobody knew. The Corps of Engineers knew. FEMA knew. None of us knew."
I could not get the White House gang to respond to the charges.
That leaves the big, big question: WHY? Why on earth would the White House not tell the state to get the remaining folks out of there?
The answer: cost. Political and financial cost. A hurricane is an act of God -- but a catastrophic failure of the levees is an act of Bush. Under law dating back to 1935, a breech of the federal levee system makes the damage -- and the deaths -- a federal responsibility. That means, as van Heeden points out, "these people must be compensated."
The federal government, by law, must build and maintain the Mississippi River levees to withstand known dangers -- or pay the price when they fail.
Indeed, that was the rule applied in the storms that hit Westhampton Dunes, New York, in 1992. There, when federal sea barriers failed, the floodwaters wiped away 190 homes. The Feds rebuilt them from the public treasury. But these were not just any homes. They are worth an average of $3 million apiece -- the summer homes of movie stars and celebrity speculators.
There were no movie stars floating face down in the Lower Ninth Ward nor in Lakeview nor in St. Bernard Parish. For the 'luvvies' of Westhampton Dunes, the federal government even trucked in sand to replace the beaches. But for New Orleans' survivors, there's the aluminum gulag of FEMA trailer parks. Today, two years later, 89,000 families still live in this mobile home Guantanamo -- with no plan whatsoever for their return.
And what was the effect of the White House's self-serving delay?
I spoke with van Heerden in his university office. The computer model of the hurricane flashed quietly as I waited for him to answer. Then he said, "Fifteen hundred people drowned. That's the bottom line."
They could have survived Hurricane Katrina. But they got no mercy from Hurricane George.
A BUZZFLASH GUEST CONTRIBUTION
For the rest of the story, get the DVD, "BIG EASY TO BIG EMPTY: The Untold Story of the Drowning of New Orleans," as reported by Greg Palast from Louisiana for Democracy Now - with Amy Goodman and the music of "the city that care forgot." Watch a clip at youtube.com/GregPalastOffice.
- Login or register to post comments
- Printer-friendly version
Buzz this on Buzzflash.net




Technorati Tags:
I'm looking for a citation, reference
Greg.
You wrote:
"Under law dating back to 1935, a breech of the federal levee system makes the damage -- and the deaths -- a federal responsibility."
Can you please provide a reference? What law? etc Thanks.
If anyone else knows the law, please post it.
•••
"Yeah, right, as if Palast actually knows anything about the subject." That's what a friend told me but I am optimist and even a bit naive so maybe Palsast will actually be able to document his statement. As I say, I'm an optimist.
http://citycomfortsblog.typepad.com/
their talk radio monopoly allows them to invent mediareality and
gives them the confidence to get away with anything.
greg, they might have been considering insurance costs but they watched 5 days of suffering after that without acting for a variety of political reasons, including the talk radio PR bonanza of racism that would result if they got the black on white violence they were hoping for but never got.
did anyone ever trace the false rumors of violence back to the rove people?
Who knew and when?
Let's broaden the view here. How many in Congress knew of this federal responsibility and therefore are just as guilty for this cover-up as the White House?
No wonder Trent Lott got immediate action.
Signature: Honesty is the first chapter in the book of wisdom. - Thomas Jefferson
Is time wrong?
The article says that the White House knew by midnight on Monday, so is "2 p.m." a typo?
Van Heerden revealed: "FEMA knew at 11 o'clock on Monday that the levees had breeched. At 2 p.m., they flew over the 17th Street Canal and took video of the breech."
2 a.m. on Tuesday morning makes more sense if the White House knew by midnight Monday. That would mean FEMA knew at 11 p.m., the White House knew by midnight, and at 2 am FEMA took aerial video.
Washington clean up
Yes, we need a clean sweep of Congress and the White House. I think we should start now, with EVERY state starting recall petitions for all Congress people. As for the White House, we need criminal trials, convictions and life sentences. We simply cannot keep electing officials within the current two party system. A third party is needed like never before.
What to do? New brooms for a clean sweep of Congress
Carol Wolman, MD
Let's hope that this story, of Bush withholding information that the levees were breaking in NO, doesn't get buried. It's a shocker, maybe big enough to break through.
I disagree with the last poster, I think we've done much more than we're given credit for. If it were not for the conscientious souls in the post office and Communicable Disease Center two weeks after 9-11, the Senate would have been decimated by anthrax, and a state of emergency declared. Or if flight 92 had hit its target- probably the Capitol, dictatorship would have started back then. I have no doubt that 9-11 was intended as a coup, which succeeded only partially.
Our resistance since then has been fierce and mostly peaceful, and it can continue to be that way. We're holding them at bay. Impeachment is still an option.
In 2008, we need to elect a Congress not beholden to corporations and the Bush junta. A Congress that will take on the "unitary executive", no matter which warmonger is in the White House.
Yes, this will take lots of organization, but it doesn't require taking to the streets or doing anything illegal. It does require working with the local Greens, or perhaps PDA's, or perhaps an independent campaign like Cindy Sheehan, and bringing together a coalition of likeminded candidates for Congress, who pledge to restore the balance of power mandated by the Constitution. New brooms for a clean sweep of Congress.
This strategy might put enough fear of losing their seats into the present Congress to get them to impeach! With their approval rating at 18%, they must be getting the message.
Impeachment is legal, peaceful and democratic. So is electoral politics. Let's not panic- don't agonize, organize.
In the name of the Peacemaker, Degandawidah,
Carol Wolman
Green preCandidate for Congress, CA District 1
Hurrican George
What makes me so upset is while these 1500 died he strumbed a guitar and ate cake. He stayed on vacation for 4 days while people died and babies went without water and diapers. These are American people. Just what does george need to do before he is driven out of office. Cheney can even shoot someone in the face. I am so sick of it all.
What's left?
Someone, anyone, correct me if I am wrong here: It is NOT POSSIBLE to hold these people accountable for their crimes and misdeeds via any of the traditional channels of law enforcement, jurisprudence, or even news-making. We can say whatever we want, they wait a few days, then they carry on.
We have been playing along in good faith, and even in bad faith some of the time. Still, nothing doing. We've had fairly massive online organization (thank you, MoveOn). We have our progressive news portals (thank you AlterNet, BuzzFlash, etc.). We've tried to get into talk radio and even onto TV a little bit (thank you Jon Stewart, Bill Maher...) and we've been allowed to have our many snide moments of much-deserved moral superiority. And now what?
Administration felonies never to be prosecuted, illegal war, civilian death approaching or surpassing a million, depending on who you read, Gonzalez not only still in his seat but being given expanded power with regard to the DEATH PENALTY of all things... and obviously this only touches the surface, the list is already too long, even if there WERE a 24-hour liberal... no scratch that, progressive... no not that, how about SLIGHTLY OBJECTIVE news channel, they'd never have enough time in a day to keep up with it.
Face it, we are moving backwards. Five clicks back for every one click forward. The best we've ever been able to do is slow the bleeding momentarily.
I wish I were a political visionary. I wish I were a born leader. I don't see any of this changing without people taking to the streets, and I am not even sure I know what that's going to mean. I don't think it means peaceful demonstrations with permits, sequestered into roped-off areas, with carefully chosen media coverage. Even the massive anti-Iraq war demonstrations, with hundreds of thousands in multiple cities, barely made a ripple in American media.
What then? What does it take? Massive orgaanization, for one thing. Which must have a lot to do with why domestic surveillance is on the increase. Am I afraid to even write this stuff? Yes. Do I imagine that this sort of publicly posted comment may crop up in the years to come with regard to loans, job applications, passport applications, voter registration? Maybe. This kind of thinking was considered paranoid fringe just ten years ago or so. MSM certainly would want to call it that now. So is it?
And if you allow that it could be true, what does that mean with regard to these lawbreakers described in the article, which seems to silently ask the question: How will these people be stopped?
I'm open to suggestions. Yes, you, in the back...
How to stop the dictatorship?
Thanks, Corndog. I agree with your evaluation of the situation: we're going backward rather than forward.
The sad thing is this: they're either in on the coup or they're playing along with it because they dig their jobs, senators, representatives, bureaucrats, whatever. They're just doing what they've been doing, and if they keep their heads down they'll keep on keeping on. Power is addictive and the ones in government are slamming it like heroin.
a new fairness doctrine will shut down their main power source
the uncontested repetition to tens of millions every day creates the flavor of America. one local blowhard with a microphone can undo the work of thousands of activist citizens. as long as the monopoly remains unchallenged progressives will continue to play without a front line. that monopoly is what has made the diffence the last 20 years.
a short term solution might be daily searchable transcripts of their proopaganda so that progressives/dems/liberals can really see the patterns and finally see the TR monopoly has been rove/GOPs most important tool.
every Dem candidate of consequence will be getting swiftboated by these blowhards, locally and nationally, and all the Dems have to do is list the lies and distortions and their frequenies on their websites or even in ads and they will finally publicize the power of TR that has been hidden so long.
Corndog's Post
During Vietnam people cared and reacted. Most now are beyond apathy, caring only about their petty interests and what is happening in the entertainment/sports industries. What you said cannot be refuted or improved. What is happening now is unparalleled. We may never recover. Thanks, Corndog.
petty interests
stevebonzai THEY WILL WAKE UP IN THE COMING DEPRESSION. THE MELTDOWN IS NOT LOCAL. THE FED PRINTING MAGIC PAPER WILL SOON MAKE IT WORTHLESS. CHINA AND MANY OTHER COUNTRIES HOLD MAGIC PAPER THAT IS BACKED, IN FULL, BY THE WORD OF GEORGE BUSH. THERE IS NO GOLD IN FORT KNOX. THERE ARE I.O.U.s IN THE SOCIAL SECURITY ACCOUNT. YOUR PENSION IS INVESTED IN A HEDGE FUND. HAVE A NICE DAY. BONZAI