Get FREE BuzzFlash News Alerts

Email:  

Star-spangled-bannered authoritarian brutes

THE FIFTH COLUMNIST by P.M. Carpenter

Yep, just one more reason to be glad the Wehrmacht went down to ignominious defeat: They and their ideological masters were, you see, as the Cliff Clavin of talk radio so knowledgeably informed us this week, "insanely, irrationally against pollution."

Not only that, as they burned and pillaged and raped and slaughtered their way through Europe and Euroasia and North Africa, wearing loutish insignia which looked -- wouldn't you just know it? -- strikingly similar to Obama's healthcare logo, they held within their black hearts a psychotic hatred of big business (which had financed their continental ravages), and wanted only to return to the fiscally profligate Fatherland, where, just like the bunch of left-leaning Nazis they were, they could enjoy "cradle-to-grave nationalized healthcare."

Those mid-century Teutons, however, probably didn't need such a comprehensive healthcare system quite as much as others, since they all stayed pretty healthy by toiling on "a whole bunch of make-work projects ... one of which was the Autobahn," and, once while taking a break from their founding of the first PETA chapter, they had "banned smoking."

I do wonder how many times that splendid little history education was repeated that evening throughout suburban America, as it prepared to patriotically search and destroy some subversive town hall meeting: "Really, Hon, it's all true, I heard it today on Rush Limbaugh." To the ramparts!

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid wondered as well; he was perplexed as the rest of us -- excluding, of course, those greasing their faces black and suiting up for subterranean combat -- and marveled aloud at the political opposition's self-destructive behavior: "They're taking their cues from talk show hosts, Internet rumormongers, and insurance rackets.... It's not often that you try to blow yourself up, but that's obviously what they're trying to do with all this vexatious stuff they're doing with these meetings," said Reid this week with uncharacteristic verve. "It's a party being run by a talk show host."

And, as noted, not very well.

In the immediate post-election period, political observers sat and pondered how the GOP might revive itself; the quickly arrived-at consensus being, it would moderate. But those boys have been full of surprises, crammed up and down and in every which way with the most counterintuitive maneuvering instead -- near-uniform hostility to an economic recovery package in response to a national crisis they caused; widespread opposition to an eminently qualified Supreme Court nominee of future election-determining heritage; and now their blessing, if not direct deployment, of corporate-financed goon squads.

"We know what we're up against," said Reid's counterpart, Nancy Pelosi. "Carpet-bombing, slash and burn, shock and awe -- anything you want to say to describe what the insurance companies will do to hold on to their special advantage"; and in the process, for reasons indecipherable to the rational mind, reduce the complicit GOP's approval rating from a solid minority to a barely detectable third-party level.

Yet, as Reid rightly observed, it's merely self-slashing and self-burning and self-shocking and awing. Most, in fact a crushing majority of Americans really, really dislike this sort of behavior -- the sort such as in St. Louis County Thursday night, where "police officers arrested six people..., some on assault charges, outside a health care and aging forum organized by [Democratic] Representative Russ Carnahan," or in Tampa, Florida, where a town hall meeting, also on Thursday, "descended into violence."

So just who are these swarming crackpots doing the undemocratic bidding of the GOP, corporate propagandists, and 501(c)3-ed gauleiters? Strangely enough, in answer to that master-educator Rush Limbaugh was on to something in his references to mid-century authoritarianism, though naturally he had the "something" all screwed up.

Last night, on MSNBC's "Countdown," there appeared a Princeton professor who, in partial explanation of the kind of human specimen likely to attend only to disrupt a town hall meeting, mentioned a contemporary scholarly manuscript on "authoritarian dynamics" which, I'm sad to confess, I have yet to read. I am, however, somewhat familiar with the larger body of work previously done in this area of socio-psycho-political derangement, principally that of Dr. Bob Altemeyer, in his Right-Wing Authoritarianism, and, originally, the groundbreaking work of Theodor Adorno et al, in their postwar The Authoritarian Personality.

That last title -- a work, admittedly, reworked by scholars because of methodological problems -- pretty much gives the guessing game away. Some, if not many, of these disruptive folks, such as those in St. Louis County and Tampa, possess the interior constitution of a pathological personality -- not only a deep susceptibility to higher authoritarian suggestion and power, but an inner authoritarian makeup so potentially violent it borders on a love of the anarchistic (hence Adorno's neologism of "pseudoconservative").

They proclaim an extreme patriotic fidelity to national and traditional values, but are fascinated by, and attracted to, the undemocratic, the brutish, the brutal. One can't reason with them, because they're irrational (often along racial and anti-ethnic lines); and on a matter such as healthcare for all, one can't appeal to their sympathy for the deprived, because they regard sympathy as a human weakness.

And that's why, three days ago, I titled a piece on this issue "Those marvelous town hall putsches," full of otherwise shrill terminology such as "brownshirts" and "stormtroopers." It's not that "they" are back; only that this twisted personality-type never left us.

 

Please respond to P.M.'s commentary by leaving comments below and sharing them with the BuzzFlash community. For personal questions or comments you can contact him at fifthcolumnistmail@gmail.com

THE FIFTH COLUMNIST by P.M. Carpenter




You are helping to polarize. Just what the Plutocracy wanted.

It serves no purpose to polarize and demonize. All you are doing is fomenting anger from the left.

You are just as much a part of the problem. But you can change, and so can they. So stop saying they can't. Stop trying to put all the blame on them when it is just as much your fault for overreacting and adding fuel to the fire.

United we stand, divided we fall. Stop trying to divide. Stop blaming them for everything. Take a good look in the mirror.

yeah right kevin

You go ahead and take that approach with these people. I dont recall blaming them for anything other than their own behavior, but I guess thats off limits too. The reason they behave in such a violent and threatening way is because they think all progressives are like you. You will reach out a hand and pull back a stump, and do it again tomorrow. If your not willing to stand up and call it what it is, you shouldnt be here. Perhaps you missed the 1st headline on this site today? Perhaps you should watch some of the footage and tell us they can change? They will gladly stomp on you and your peace offering. Its this kind of passive liberalism that has allowed these people to demonize the very word liberal for 30 years, and make it fashionable to threaten us on our own territory. That kind of liberalism has gotten us to the point we are at now, complete control of the government and still being ruled by the minority. Pathetic. The purpose it serves is to wake people up to do more than scold with their keyboards.

The internet can also be used for historical research..

Try researching the failed "coup" on the FDR White House....Smedley Butler....or Founders of the American Fascist Party....even American Fascism Families of the 1920's, 30's and 40's... (Here's a partial list of those who were trying to shut down FDR's (socialistic) New Deal, (which originally included Health Care for all, but was stopped by (guess who?) ....any of the names and Corporations sound familiar...? There are some links provided too...the right has tried to bury, re-write and/or distort this "Dark Chapter in American History"...but its still accessible through internet and library research) Prescott Bush (W's. Grandpappy)was also reported to have been heavily involved.. XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Some of the other prominent figures in American finance and industry involved in this coup plot were "leading officers of the Morgan and Du Pont empires. This included some of America's richest and most famous names of the time: Irenee Du Pont - Right-wing chemical industrialist and founder of the American Liberty League, the organization assigned to execute the plot. Grayson Murphy - Director of Goodyear, Bethlehem Steel and a group of J.P. Morgan banks. William Doyle - Former state commander of the American Legion and a central plotter of the coup. John Davis - Former Democratic presidential candidate and a senior attorney for J.P. Morgan. Al Smith - Roosevelt's bitter political foe from New York. Smith was a former governor of New York and a codirector of the American Liberty League. John J. Raskob - A high-ranking Du Pont officer and a former chairman of the Democratic Party. In later decades, Raskob would become a "Knight of Malta," a Roman Catholic Religious Order with a high percentage of CIA spies, including CIA Directors William Casey, William Colby and John McCone. Robert Clark - One of Wall Street's richest bankers and stockbrokers. Gerald MacGuire - Bond salesman for Clark, and a former commander of the Connecticut American Legion. MacGuire was the key recruiter to General Butler." http://www.dailykos.com/story/2005/2/27/112936/440 ; http://www.huppi.com/kangaroo/Coup.htm

That 23%...don't Activate them

Some of these studies were referenced in John Dean's recent book "Conservatives Without Conscience." And if memory serves, I believe the studies showed that 23% of any given population has an authoritarian mindset, whether that be leaders or followers. I see this as the number of people with a genetic predisposition to have the type of brain likely to lead one in this authoritarian direction, a pathology, if you will. These people are not necessarily dangerous in and of themselves, and we have lived among them mostly in peace for years, even with significant liberal majorities in Congress. But, as with some brain pathologies, they can remain dormant and benign until something activates them into malignancy. I believe the authoritarian pathology has now been activated in the U.S., and on a more fullscale level than at any other time in my life. The activation of the few began with the repeal of the Fairness Doctrine and the rise of Rush Limbaugh. But now there are a thousand Limbaughs. We have had 30 years of a constant, withering stream of fullscale lies, hate and propangada against liberals on rightwing radio. Some people hear this drivel 8 hours a day. Now they can also watch it on Fox TV. Brains are becoming altered on a massive scale. So over a period of time the authoritarian activation began. With the recent uptick in violent rhetoric I believe the malignant activation is reaching a critical mass. What we are seeing now, I fear, is the beginning of the mass insanity of 23% of our fellow citizens. The genie has been let out of the bottle. This is the authoritarian brain on steroids. Activated. En masse. On some level I feel sorry for the followers, because even though they would hate me for my beliefs and in some cases visit violence upon me, I must recognize that many of them are truly sick in a psychiatric sense. I can only hope that this doesn't end up where it has so often in history when this type of populace is activated. We can only hope...

Low-Information Losers

They're as mad as hell, and they're not going to take being powerless, marginalized, terrified nobodies anymore. Limbaugh and his ilk give these people an identity and a sense of self-importance. The issues don't matter, obviously since they're working against their own well-being.They want to be seen and heard, period. Well one day Boss Limbaugh will be gone, and they will be lost. But before that, they will have lost any claim to dignity and humanity they could have had. Tragic for them and tragic for the country they are damaging with their blind flailing cries for recognition.

Didn't Stalin execute a few...

officers whom, it was said, agreed that they had been bad communists and deserved to die? Yes, the Hitler connection is ironic. He _was_ very big on personal responsibility in health.

An Interesting Tidbit

Adorno's work contains an interesting insight into these morons. If their leader should deem them to become a threat for some reason, they universally believe that their leader should round them all up and imprison them - if not take more extreme measures. They are so enamored of authoritarian power that they would do anything, even that which goes against their personal interest and safety, to serve that power. The closest historical example that most Americans would recognize is the attitude displayed by the Japanese people serving the Emperor during the Pacific War. He word was their life - literally. So it is with "birthers" and cops profiling Obama and Dittoheads and the Beck Bund and ...

beware of history

These crazys need to be taken seriously. It was a tiny but very loud group of crazys just like them that managed to intimidate the entire German nation and eventually seize power in 1933. The right wing has been planting and nursing a climate of fear in america for a decade now. This wasnt done without reason. They are all too knowledgeable in how constant fear makes the body politic vulnerable to the paranoid fantasies of authoritarian dictator types. Their leaders in the media are experts at projection, as is the entire GOP party doctrine, and with the "mainstream media" ready and willing to amplify and legitimize their crazy behavior, know it has a good chance of scaring the uninformed masses and succeeding. We have already seen some of their foot soldiers take up their 4th amendment protected weaponry and turn it on people they see as their enemies and I fear this deranged and WELL ARMED segment of society is ripe to be turned loose on the general population. The majority of people in this country are so dazed and afraid that they refuse to see what is so obvious and wont take action until it is far too late. The irony in being called nazis by nazis is priceless but not the least bit funny. These are dangerous days and I fear worse to come.

agreed

I fear it will take a massacre to wake people from their slumber about the true danger of these nuts. I've been having a vision of a rightwinger mowing down a group of liberals with an Uzi for weeks. I'm not a prophet (of course) so hopefully this is a false image which will never come to pass. But I can't seem to shake it. Recent events have not helped the situation.

Keep in mind--

-that the rise of Adolph in the 1930's was also aided by a minority which was rejected and disbursed. Somehow it held on and kept the absurd tempo of "super-race" as their mantra along with race baiting, minority baiting -it was not incidental that insiders to this maniac rise in Germany included the Prescott Bush and Ford bunch who aided and contributed then and continue to drive it now in this nation. They well understand the power of 'sympathy'--look wasn't george a 'compassionate' Republican fellow? In words only. The 20% or so whose insanity is discussed here is activated by those same preGerman proAdolph forces that are firmly established here and who can do anything about it? Lied for wars, control of the Media and control of the Judiciary, they got it.

all too true

You are spot on about the control of the media and the judiciary. When you look closer they also have control of the legislative branch, through the corrupt system of campaign finance. There are very few members of congress in either party who are interested in whats best for the people they represent, or for the nation as a whole. Most are now bent on keeping themselves in power and using that power to enrich themselves and their cronies. In the US, democracy is already dead, and has been replaced by a corporate and lobby financed oligarchy. The executive branch is also in the loop as the "candidates" for this office are chosen by the media and financed by the same corporations who own the media. The real definition of fascism, is the blending of state and corporate power. The present trend of the concentration of all power into the executive branch(as practiced by the last 5 presidents, including Obama) is the next logical step in the march to dictatorship. The gutting of the public education system insures that the majority of people has no clue about how the government is supposed to function, and this combined with the never ending propaganda from the "news media" has the country set up as ripe for these authoritarian zombie wingnuts. Until the masses are completely fleeced and left starving in the streets, nothing to stop this is going to happen.