Get FREE BuzzFlash News Alerts

Email:  

Are We Witnessing the First Stages of a Violent Right-Wing Open Rebellion? George Tiller Is Not a Lone Victim.

A BUZZFLASH NEWS ANALYSIS
by Christine Bowman

A "pro-lifer" fires a bullet point-blank into a doctor's head in a church foyer, then lands a 30-minute interview with CNN from inside his jail. Not to be outdone, a lifelong, anti-Semitic White supremacist opens fire with a rifle and kills a Black Holocaust Memorial Museum security guard in a building filled with school children and tourists. What's next from right-wing extremists?

Even as a fresh horror unfolded today at the Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, D.C., it looks like the opportunistic Randall Terrys and CNNs of the world have decided to turn the murder of Dr. George Tiller into the next "family values" media circus along the lines of the Terri Schiavo debacle that went down in 2003-2005. (Randall Terry was at the center of that one, too.) Right-wing extremists, with their "pro life" murder suspect Scott Roeder leading the charge from his Sedgwick County, Kansas jail cell, are once again seizing upon tragedy to push their extreme right-wing political and religious agendas even further. They refuse to allow traumatized families to grieve in peace.

The scary part is that it might be working for them. The extremists on the right have got "the big mo" -- momentum, that is -- and hungry reporters are more than willing to add fuel to an emotionally hot story that combines murder with a political angle. Here's what some war-on-women, right-wing extremists have recently done:

  • One of only three high-profile doctors offering emergency late-term abortion procedures has been eliminated by execution.
  • One of only three clinics offering such services nationwide has been permanently shuttered.
  • One anti-abortion group claims to be interested in buying the clinic property from the dead doctor's widow.
  • A high-profile leader is comparing the murder of Dr. Tiller to the Nat Turner slave rebellion and asking, "What will we do in this hour of trial?" (His answer is to gain energy from the atrocious act.) Speaking of the pro-choice opposition, he adds: "... And now consider the proponents of child killing. ... In their perverted, ethically depraved world, we - the defenders of life - are the terrorists and villains in this epic struggle ..."
  • A Baptist minister, Wilie Drake in California, told his radio audience he had been praying for Dr. Tiller's death. He says God answered his prayers; and he prays now for President Obama's death. (Rev. Drake was Alan Keyes' American Independent Party running mate in 2008. Keyes had been Obama's right-wing opponent in the 2004 Senate race.)
  • Dan Holman of "Missionaries to the Preborn" said of Tiller's death: "I was cheered by it." He told CNN that "all abortionists are deserving of death, and that "politicians and judges, and others who support this murder are also deserving of death. ... George Bush, Barack Obama -- any politician that gives our tax money to Planned Parenthood and organizations that kill babies or participate in the killing of children deserve the same penalty."

There's nothing like a cold-blooded murder in a church to rally the right, apparently. But how does a political movement, in this case anti-abortion activists, energize and escalate beyond murder? Hopefully, mass murder and armed insurrection won't be next -- but there is that pre-Civil War model that their leader held up this week. And the NRA has been stirring up the right with advice to build up their arsenals.

Today, of course, another person took action in Washington. (How odd it sounds, to hear the lifelong, gun-wielding hater and repeat offender referred to on cable news programs as an elderly "gentleman" -- just because he is in his eighties?)

Getting back to the abortion rights battlefront, though, on the media side, CNN's Scott Rowlands -- lead reporter on CNN's Laci Peterson coverage (enough said?) -- is helpfully bringing the message of the jailed "pro-life" extremist to "mainstream" news. Of course, Roeder himself got the ball rolling by contacting the AP briefly on June 4 from jail to complain about "being treated as a criminal." One of his remarks to the AP contained some menace: "I know there are many other similar events planned around the country as long as abortion remains legal." That may have stirred up law enforcement people; it definitely interested reporters.

Soon after, CNN lined up a 30-minute interview with Roeder at the jail. The appreciative prisoner repaid the network with an excellent soundbite -- declaring "a victory for all the unborn children" and going on at some length with his imaginings about cut up fetuses.

Yet, a Tiller family lawyer chooses not to give Roeder's statements (or those of his unjailed allies in terrorist fear-mongering) legs by offering any response.

An attorney for Tiller wouldn't discuss the [clinic purchasing] proposal. "I'm just not going to respond to every irreverent publicity stunt or comment by these extremists," said the attorney, Dan Monnat.

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jaLZyHUZ2vWSrE1Go3eZ1qUW47GgD98NSUJ00

Attorney Monnat also said:

Speaking for myself ... I am reluctant to in any way legitimize Mr. Roeder, or anything he stands for, by directly responding to his statements. I am content to let law enforcement determine whether anything he says merits attention. I do not encourage anyone else to give Mr. Roeder or his extremist views any additional attention as he awaits trial.

http://community.thenest.com/cs/ks/forums/thread/17172329.aspx

So it's "Rah, rah, hit 'em again, harder," from the right. And only restrained and silent dignity in response. Reminiscent of Germany, some decades back?

Remember when a Homeland Security memo was leaked in April warning of potential violence to come from the right-wing extremists? "The job of DHS is to assess the threat of terrorism, including home-grown terrorism," spokesperson Sara Kuban said then. Every conservative speaker in politics or the media was "outraged!"

With Scott Roeder still spewing vitriol from jail, and "right-to-life" leaders fueling the hateful rage from their perches as free citizens, and CNN, among others, enabling the radicals to spread their hate, just to get a sensationalistic scoop -- isn't it time for some citizen rage from the center and left?

Hate and homegrown terrorism ran rampant in 20th-century Nazi Germany. How ironic, that they are on a roll again, here and now, in the USA. If good people look away rather than confront that fact, just how good are they?

Related, from BuzzFlash:

WINGS OF JUSTICE --George Tiller, MD

Jill Stanek Proves That the Two Remaining Doctors Who Perform Late-Term Abortions Should Be Worried

Don't Kid Yourself; the Murder of Dr. George Tiller is Part of the War Against Women

Standing in front of a tank? Assassination? How far would you go in the name of protest?

A BUZZFLASH NEWS ANALYSIS




Death Penalty

Normally, I am opposed to capital punishment. But can anybody connected to the Roeder prosecution explain to me why the death penalty is not being sought in this case? The crime was pre-meditated, the murder was carried out in a public place where other bystanders could have been harmed or killed, and the alleged perp has promised MORE killings. This would seem to be exactly the type of case proponents of cp would use for their argument for its effectiveness as a deterrent. If cp is not used in THIS case, it should never be used again.

It's a long shot

Kansas has a death penalty statute with 8 "aggravating circumstances which could qualify for the death penalty, none of which (as of yet) appear to apply to Roeder. If the feds can show that Roeder conspired with someone, they could prosecute him for violating Title 18, U.S.C., Section 241, Conspiracy Against Rights. This statute makes it unlawful for two or more persons to conspire to injure, oppress, threaten, or intimidate any person of any state, territory or district in the free exercise or enjoyment of any right or privilege secured to him/her by the Constitution or the laws of the United States, (or because of his/her having exercised the same).

Long story short, unless they can show that Roeder was paid to do it, or a conspiracy with another party (with the Feds assuming jurisdiction), it ain't gonna happen.

Thank you, both yman and christine

Thank you both for the explanation. Although I think circumstances 2 (the church was crowded) and 6 (the murder was committed in a church) could apply.

As I said, I am normally opposed to the death penalty. My point was if it is not asked for it here, it should never be asked for again.

Once again, thank you both for the replies.

Peace

Death penalty

Kansas only allows the death penalty in a limited range of cases, such as those involving multiple deaths.

Their hate speech is domestic terrorism

Their hate speech is not protected under the Constitution as free speech. Rather it is most certainly domestic terrorism.

Re: Tiller murder...

OK, I am pro-life but I am also a realist. I am throughly opposed to abortion just as I am even more opposed to creating an industry of "BACK ALLEY ABORTION PROVIDERS" which is what the overturning of Roe v Wade would produce. The Right in their self-righteous outrage on "baby killers" are doing what they seem to do best: Stick their heads in the sand and pretend that "ever' thin's jes' fine!' if they get their way (and their way is the ONLY way). The right isn't only concerned with abortion, they are also deeply concerned with sex education, and contraception, promoting an ABSTINENCE ONLY approach and refusing to see the fallacy of that view, being: that ignorance and lack of protection is the best safegard against unwanted pregnancy. The rate of unwanted pregnancies has gone up whenever this attitude against contraception and has prevailed, creating with it the demand for abortions. The rate of abortion has gone down when the attitude of "legal, safe and RARE" has prevailed. The question remains, do we want abortions rarely done in a safe, clean environment or in a back alley with a dirty coat-hanger.

Love the fetus, hate the child.

Even women who have abortions are "pro-life". I am a pro-choice woman who at the tender age of 18 was faced with the decision...abort or not. At that time it was illegal, but that has never stopped any woman since the beginning of time to choose when to reproduce. There are always (and always will be) ways to abort a fetus. I chose to have my baby and gave him up for adoption, but have known many women who have chosen differently. The point is, we have a right to have a CHOICE of what we want to do. If you are opposed to abortion, don't have one. Pretty simple stuff. If the right-wingers cared as much for the welfare of the fetus AFTER it was born, they might not seem so hypocritical. But they don't want them to have health-care, schooling, clothes, food, shelter or parents. What kind of pro-life is that?

to katnip at 2:59PM

Janejane - I agree with this writer.She is so right, especially the last portion, regarding the cost of raising that child with good health-care, clothes, etc.

General Sherman was too

General Sherman was too nice, the traitor Confederates led by Jefferson Davis - the traitor - the mass killer who slaughtered more Americans than Hitler, Stalin, King George, and Osama combined. Racists have always been the worst enemies of Americans, they have killed by far more Americans. Racists are burdened with such stagerring ignorance that they are the most willing pawns of authoritarians - throwing their own life away over nothing - over a false claim that its supposedly necessary to have a race war - long after the vast majority of Americans understand at long last Conservative LIES about how its supposedly necessary to go to war - and there isnt any race problem in America that racists didnt cause after having been stirred up by authoritarians who use them as pawns.

Class war, not race war

This is just another divide and conquer tactic used by the plutocracy to maintain their strangle hold on the country.

Republicans vs. Democrats, white vs. black vs. brown, pro abortion vs. anti abortion, gay marriage vs. biblical marriage, Christian nation vs. separation of church and state. Our anger should be directed towards the plutocracy and not each other.

What the plutocracy doesn't want you to know:

United we stand,
divided we fall.
E Pluribus Unum,
From the many, one
WE THE PEOPLE!

No right-wing private army???

You think there is no private army available to the neo-facists in this country? Ever heard of a little company called Halliburton? Who do you think the wealthy hired in New Orleans to keep the drowning rabble out of their drowned mansions after Katrina? Wake up people...

Blackwater aka Xe

Blackwater is most certainly a right-wing private army. They came to power under Dubya/dick and won't go away unless we prosecute them for war crimes committed in Iraq, and end all contracts between them and the U.S., state and local governments.

Right-wingers rebelling against?

We have right-wing government. Who the hell are these people rebelling against? I'd say they're using right-wing power against a minority in this pro-fascist land. Government by the rich, for the rich and of the rich since 1789, and proud of it.

I should have made it clear

Mike1001, I'm about as far as you can get from a white supremacist.I posted that to show how acts of violence on an individual basis are being promoted by these sick bastards. I ran across an article about the Aryan Nation regrouping and took a look at their web site. I wasn't ready for the extent of violence being promoted there, it's pretty disgusting.

Thanks...

Missed the irony, there---my apologies. I read the right-wing sites, too (the Corleone philosophy---keep your friends close and your enemies closer). One tries to be committed to peace, and I have been since fighting the draft (legally) in 1972; but it is VERY hard sometimes, especially since the violence against anyone classified as the "other", usually people of color and women; is systemic. Something I read recently that is slightly off this specific topic, but has a deep relationship to it, in the sense of releasing yourself from the cycle of violence---I would recommend to all, on the blog Feral Scholar: http://www.feralscholar.org/blog/index.php/2008/09/14/open-letter-to-christian-us-troops-in-iraq-and-afghanistan/

You must have no picture

You must have no picture whatsoever of the level and type of violence characterizing the Nazi era in Germany, or you wouldn't have drawn such a lame parallel. You think Barack Obama is Schleicher or something? What we have going on here is more like lynching, which in this country has a long and ugly history.

Mr. Rebel Yell...

For a white supremacist, you certainly sound like one of Osama's boyz, or perhaps a Likud party member. Proof positive that xenophobia, racism, and extermminist beliefs know no boundaries of race, religion, or creed. Get a life---be kind to your neighbors (no matter what color they are), look at growing good food for post Peak-Oil times (it's coming, whether you people believe it or not), and read The Politics of Jesus, by John Howard Yoder.

Right Wing Terror Mimics Blackshirt Brownshirt Fascist Tactics

I do not agree that we are becoming "overly dramatic" in this instance. Neither Mussolini's Fascist movement in Italy nor the Nazi movement in Germany ever represented a majority in either country. Instead they bullied and terrorized their way into power, as the respective governments in both countries gave way. It's time to ramp up the pressure on these home grown Fascist thugs. We have no Edward R. Murrows in the press to take them on in this day and age. But we should take to heart what Murrow once said in answer to criticism re: taking on Joe McCarthy: "Sometimes there aren't two sides to a story." There is no "good side" to Fascist terror.

This is so damn lame; the

This is so damn lame; the Nazis had a private army. Where is the Republican private army marching through the streets of our cities? The comparison is a left-leaning mirror image of Michele Bachmann. Even with the Bushists we never had anything but (murderous, contemptible) little kiddies play-acting that they were the Japanese Empire or something (and Bush actually got bored with it after a while and stopped playing).

open your mind

the right wing has blackwater,private little state militias we have all heard about.Obama appointed a fundamentalist congressman as head of the army who has spoken for the overtrow of the United States by the fundamentalist.The air force academy is run as a Fundamentalist academy where those who don't agree with the Fundamentalist religion are beaten and hazed.Mr. Sdhwartz get your head out of your butt.The question you should be asking is what army does America have left to defend itself against the right wing.We could also talk about media control and our constitution being destroyed little by little.As a jew you should recognize the signs

1,000,000 is about the

1,000,000 is about the consensus outside of Conservative circles - as to the number of Iraqis slaughtered - and Conservatives tried as hard as they could to start a war against the Iranians. If Bush wasnt stopped Bush would have gotten to 6,000,000.

come on

For God's sake , we are getting just a little overly dramatic and carried away here don't you think ? Comparing the actions of a few right wing nut jobs in this country to " the hate and homegrown terrorism ran rampant in 20th-century Nazi Germany " ? I'm on your side of the issue but this is just a wee bit over the top , how do you expect to be taken seriously ? Sometimes I am embarrassed to be a lefty .

No, "We're" Not

It is not over the top at all, and Bowman's piece is quite accurate. Why the hell is Roeder being legitimized by the media whores at CNN? Instead of condemning this man's actions, he's suddenly ready for prime-time fame? He is a domestic terrorist who just murdered a man in cold blood in a f****** church! Dr. Tiller had been harassed and shot previously. Why didn't the FBI and local law enforcement prevent Roeder from assassinating Tiller? And, what were the recent shootings in Pittsburgh, the Unitarian church in Tennessee last year, and now the Holocaust musuem all about? Spend a little time educating yourself by looking at Talktoaction.org, and some of Fred Clarkson's reporting. Also, Americans United for the Separation of Church and State, another excellent organization which has been fighting religious extremism for decades. A few years ago, I didn't think there was much need for alarm, but now after learning of the depth and severity of wingnut extremism in this country, we have every reason to be concerned, as well as to ACT on those concerns. Saying nothing at all or poo-pooing the whole thing will come back to bite all our lefty asses. Because it's not "just a few right wing nut jobs," it's a well organized movement with domestic terrorists armed and ready to murder their next victim. So, don't be embarassed, do something about it.

read

There have been numerous books written about Fundamentalist terrorism in this country.The leaders of the Fundamentalist movement want to destroy America and have stated they want a Christian state under their leadership with all non Christians put to death which means liberals,homosexuals or anyone who disagrees with them.They are working to control the army and do control the air force academy.My question is when will you take this seriously when they are at your door