Phil Gramm: "We live in the only country in the world where all the poor people are fat"
A BUZZFLASH NEWS ANALYSIS
by Amy Weiss
The "nation of whiners" quote, where John McCain's economic adviser Phil Gramm accused the country of being in a "mental recession" received a great deal of national attention, but it's not the first time Gramm has displayed insensitivity for struggling Americans.
In his 1984 Senate campaign in Texas, Gramm allegedly said "Has anyone ever noticed that we live in the only country in the world where all the poor people are fat?" a quote also attributed to Dinesh D'Souza and a favorite of right-wingers leaving comments on Web sites disparaging the American welfare system.
In the same campaign, his opponent ran commercials "portraying Mr. Gramm as saying that the elderly deserved no sympathy because few people had the 'luxury' of living to 80 and that Federal budget provisions for the handicapped encouraged people to be crippled. "
Obviously, the ad content must be taken with a grain of salt due to the extremely contentious nature of that campaign, but given Gramm's unsympathetic attitude towards the poor, it doesn't seem so far-fetched.
Bob Herbert once said, "The insufferable Phil Gramm likes to talk about people riding in the wagon while others do all the pulling." He also characterized the atmosphere in the Senate after a welfare reform bill Gramm helped lead the effort on was passed as "millionaires celebrating the stomping of the poor."
A political science professor said of Gramm: "He is diabolically smart, but he makes no concessions to small talk and does not do well communicating with people he feels are his intellectual inferiors."
Does that include Mr. "I don't really understand the economy," John McCain?
Gramm told an opponent once, "I feel so sorry for your many problems, but you deserve them."
Just like poor people deserve to be poor ... and fat. And just like hardworking Americans deserve to be struggling in a recession that's all in their heads.
A BUZZFLASH NEWS ANALYSIS
- Login or register to post comments
- Printer-friendly version
Buzz this on Buzzflash.net




Technorati Tags:
.
Poor people are fat
Fat Head Phil
The Same Country Where The Poor Die From Lack Of Health Care
phil gramm - American disgrace
Gramm and McCain are the disgrace
Oooops, my mistake
Not smart and a pig at the public trough
Pig at the trough
Librarian ejected from McCain Venue
Uh
So Rush Limbaugh is poor?
Please keep talking Phil
Fill up from a Phil up
So many years...
phil graham
Social Darwinism at its most
Social Darwinism at its most flagrant. I hope Gramm keeps shooting his mouth off. He makes it so easy to identify who the real enemy of the people are.
And it ain't liberals.
But..
The proposition that the
Great Comments on Buzzflash reGramm
Graham's Comment is Wrong in Two Ways
Simple First: The US is hardly the only country where poor people are "fat" - this was, in fact, a huge problem in Great Britain and the rest of the Industrialized World in the late 19th and early 20th Centuries. There as here, it was mainly due to diets heavy in carbohydrates and fats and low in proteins and vitamins, resulting in malnutrition in the working classes.
Which leads to the Clearly Intentional - Graham must know full well those poor Americans are "fat" not b/c of good nutrition like he as a rich guy is getting, but b/c of malnutrition because they eat lots of empty carbs and fats, since they're much cheaper than food that's actually good for you. I should know, b/c I'm trying to change my own eating habits in order to eat healthier - and fish and a salad, or chicken and hummus, cost me about double what a burger and fries, or a couple slices of pizza, do!
Anyway, the quote's about a quarter-century old so it's not an immediate GOTCHA! But - as the Rethugs liked to say about Slick Willie when he was President, "It speaks to his character...." ;)
The Poor are being Annihilated
What a Schmuck!
There are two kinds of Republicans: millionaires and suckers.
What an ass.
Whole Paycheck
The Blowhard
Blowhard
The only whining I hear comes from the right
Ya ever notice that.
It's the wing nuts of this country who're always whining, complaining that somebody lower down the economic ladder is getting some kind of government freebie that they aren't, so nobody should get it.
They're always whining that all their paycheck goes to taxes which go to "government" schools, highway maintenance and, especially, welfare.
But yet not one of these hard-charging, stand-on-my-own-two feet Ayn Rand-cultist, Ted Nugent-fans or Rush Limbaugh-listeners ever misses a chance to line up for free cheese, collect a FEMA check or bitch out the DOT everytime they drive over a pothole.
Frankly, I wish all the Ayn Rand-cultists, Ted Nugent-fans and Rush Limbough-listeners would take the advice of the late Jack E. Leonard and put their shoes on and get the hell outta here!
There curently are several countries were taxes are low and governmental services, aside from the police, courts and military, are non-existant: Somolia, Haiti, Afghanistan and Iraq.
I wish they would all emigrate to one of the above free market paradises with Phil and Wendy Gramm leading them like Moses leading the Children of Israel out of Egypt.
To that, I'd say good ridance.
If you're wondering...
Gramm's Greatest Hits
GRAMM CRACKER, THE CRUMB!
Gramm floats in his LAISSIEZ FAIRYLAND
PHIL " GUMP " GRAMM *
So many Republicans?
There are not that many Republicans! However, it does not take that much of something bad to stink up something good. Have your chihuahua "pitch a loaf" into a batch of fine wine - now you have a large batch of liquid dog poop.
How many skunks does it take to completely fark up a lawn party?
Just one moderately loud egg salad with onion and green-beer fart at a nun's wake?
McCain and Gramm are common variety garden slugs. You always know where they are - simply follow the slime. BOTH THESE BUFFOONS HAVE BEEN ON THE GOVERNMENT DOLE ALL THEIR PARASITIC LIVES.
As Casey Stengel used to say, "Ya' cud look it up!"
The Skeptical Cynic hath spake!
Santa knows when you are sleeping,
He knows when you're awake.
He knows if you've been bad or good.
Unfortunately, so does Bush,
Cheney, Rice, Mukasey, and...
the FBI, ONI, CIA, MCIA, NSA,
DIA,MI6, MOSSAD, AIPAC,
PHIL " GUMP " GRAMM